Skip to Content

The 7 Best Velveeta Cheese Substitutes

Whether you’re using cheese in a recipe, or you like a slice of cheese and crackers in the evening, cheese plays a huge role in the kitchen.

The 7 Best Velveeta Cheese Substitutes

What Is Velveeta Cheese?

There are thousands of different cheeses, all with different textures and tastes. Velveeta cheese is a type of processed cheese, vaguely similar to traditional American cheese.

Notably, it is the brand name, but most people refer to it as Velveeta cheese, as it’s become a family favorite.

One reason Velveeta cheese is so popular is that it’s easy to melt. It’s often used in sauces, dips, and sometimes for a good old-fashioned grilled cheese It’s also very soft and smooth. It’s the type of cheese that melts perfectly in a microwave and on a stove.

Now, cheesemongers aren’t particularly keen on this cheese, due to the fact it’s highly processed. It’s mostly made out of whey, milk, fat, and some preservatives.

It didn’t start that way, though, it was once made with real cheese. Likewise, it changed mostly due to mass production — because it’s much cheaper to make cheese that way.

Regardless of whether cheesemongers consider Velveeta to be real cheese, it’s still a firm favorite.

Dry Cheese Vs. Soft Cheese

Velveeta cheese is considered to be soft cheese. Soft cheeses generally have a low melting point, which means that they will melt fast, and are easy to cook with. They are usually very smooth, and creamy.

Dry cheese is very different from soft cheese. If you compared a slice of Parmesan cheese to a slice of Velveeta cheese, you’d see some obvious differences.

For instance, dry cheese has a high melting point. This means it takes much longer for dry cheese to melt. Also, dry cheese doesn’t liquify.

If you’ve ever tried to make mac and cheese with a hard slab of cheese, you’ll notice that sometimes it just clumps together, rather than spreading out. Dry cheese also has more of a tangy flavor, while soft cheese is much gentler on the taste buds.

How Can I Replace Velveeta Cheese?

If you’re looking for a substitution for Velveeta cheese, look no further. Whether you just want to try a new glorious cheese, or you couldn’t find your favorite cheese when you popped into the shops, I can help you find a cheese that you will love.

We’re going to be looking at the following replacements for Velveeta cheese. It will be cheddar cheese, Swiss cheese, pepper jack, American cheese, Cheez Whiz, Eden cheese, and extra sharp cheddar cheese.

The 7 Best Velveeta Cheese Substitution

With that said, let’s look at the 7 best Velveeta cheese substitutions, so you can discover the perfect replacement.

Mild Cheddar Cheese

The first substitution for Velveeta Cheese is cheddar cheese.

Okay, so I might not be introducing you to a new, exciting cheese — but I am introducing you to a great substitution for Velveeta cheese.

Cheddar cheese is a highly popular cheese, and it is used in so many recipes. Whether it’s grilled cheese, sandwiches, or even grated onto pasta — it’s versatile. It has a slightly bitter flavor and a certain level of creaminess.

It also tastes great when melted, and for a dry cheese, does not have an overly low melting point.

The good thing about mild cheese is that if it’s for your family, especially with youngsters, it’s going to be closer to the taste of Velveeta. It’s a lot less bitter and is more creamy.

While it won’t have the exact flavor and color of Velveeta, it’ll still be a crowd-pleaser.

Swiss Cheese

The second substitution for Velveeta Cheese is Swiss cheese.

When it comes to Swiss cheese, you have so many options. I would recommend going for Emmental and Gruyère. That’s because these are very creamy cheeses, and have a mild nutty flavor.

They’re also similar in color to Velveeta, given that they have a yellow tone to them. Unlike Velveeta, these are ‘real’ cheeses, so you’ll be getting a more authentic taste.

It’s also healthier than Velveeta, so if you’re into nutrition, it could be an honest substitute.

The mild nutty flavor that belongs to Emmental and Gruyère is vital because it adds an aspect of sharpness to the cheese. This comes with aging (see, things do get better with age).

When it comes to their melting point, they melt moderately. It will not melt as fast as Velveeta, nor will it liquefy the same.

However, depending on what you’re making, e.g. mac and cheese, if you add a bit of milk, it should help even out that cheese flavor. Swiss cheese is a great alternative to Velveeta and is definitely worth a try.

Sharp Cheddar Cheese

The third substitution for Velveeta Cheese is sharp cheddar cheese.

You really didn’t think I would bring up cheddar cheese only once, did you? Cheddar cheese is more complex than a lot of people think. You have white mild, mild, sharp cheddar cheese, extra sharp cheddar… you see where I’m going with this.

Sharp cheddar cheese is ideal for those with a strong palette. It mostly works if you plan on melting the cheese because once it’s melted, it’ll taste creamy and salty.

You will have to be patient when melting, though, as it does have a low melting point.

Anyway, sharp cheddar cheese is a great alternative to Velveeta cheese. If you want to try even more variations of cheddar cheese, keep in mind that they all taste different, no cheddar cheese should be under the same label.

Pepper Jack

The fourth substitution for Velveeta Cheese is pepper jack cheese

So, this is where I introduce you to a new kind of cheese. Chances are you’ve had pepper jack before, but how often do you really use it?

Pepper jack cheese is a semisoft cheese, meaning that it can melt and liquefy reasonably well. It also has a smooth consistency, similar to Velveeta.

So, the obvious difference between Velveeta cheese and pepper jack cheese, is that pepper jack cheese is kinda spicy. It’s made with sweet peppers, chilies, and rosemary.

The thing is, if you plan on adding some spice to your dish already, then you may as well have pepper jack cheese. If you want a grilled cheese with a kick, try the pepper jack. It’s even great grated.

It’s a great cheese to have, which is why I’m putting it as a great Velveeta substitution. Although the taste is different, they have a similar texture, and it works well melted.

Cheez Whiz

The fifth substitution for Velveeta Cheese is Cheez Whiz.

I know that some of you out there are just begging me to recommend you a decent, highly processed cheese. Well, this is for you. Cheez Whiz is very processed, it’s made out of wheat, oil, and preservatives.

Cheez Whiz has the closest color to Velveeta, given that they’re both processed. It also has a very similar consistency, as it’s a soft cheese.

The good aspect of Cheez Whiz is that it should last for a couple of months in the refrigerator, so if you need a cheese that can last longer, Cheez Whiz is for you.

It generally works best with sandwiches, BBQ, and crackers. It is a very good substitute for Velveeta.

Eden Cheese

Eden Cheese

The sixth substitution for Velveeta Cheese is Eden cheese.

This is another processed cheese, which is why it works as a great substitute for Velveeta cheese. It’s incredibly soft – arguably softer than Velveeta cheese.

It’s also incredibly creamy. Given that it’s a soft cheese, it melts very easily and liquifies well.

When it comes to flavor, Eden cheese tastes very mild. It will not overpower your dish, so it’s not ideal for a dish that relies on cheese, like mac and cheese.

However, it’s a great substitute for Velveeta cheese if you’re making sandwiches, or adding it to a dish as a means to compliment.

American Cheese

The seventh substitution for Velveeta Cheese is American cheese.

We couldn’t do an article on cheese replacements, without mentioning good old fashion American Cheese.

It’s one of the closest substitutions to Velveeta cheese, due to its soft and creamy texture. It’s also super smooth, like Velveeta cheese.

American cheese has a good level of saltiness, so be careful not to add too much extra salt to your dish. American cheese melts very easily, which is useful when replacing Velveeta, except for one thing. It also burns real easily.

That isn’t much of a problem, though, just be wary of it while cooking. American cheese is perfect for mac and cheese, and any pasta dish.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Processed Cheese, Or Regular Cheese, Better At Melting?

Generally speaking, processed cheese will be better at melting, compared to regular cheese. If you remember that the harder the cheese, the longer it will take to melt, then it makes it easier to vague the melting point of cheese.

So, given that processed cheese is very soft and smooth, it makes sense that it would have a low melting point. Take Parmesan, for example, it is a much harder cheese.

Likewise, it has a high melting point because it takes more heat to melt it.

What Is Processed Cheese?

Processed cheese is not 100% cheese. In many cases, it might not even contain any traces of cheese, in other cases, it will contain around 50% of real cheese.

It is cut with salt, preservatives, dairy, and many other ingredients, to make it long-lasting and easy to melt.

Is Processed Cheese Healthy?

Processed cheese is not particularly healthy, as in some cases, it only contains 50% of real cheese. With that said, it’s all about moderation. It isn’t healthy to eat loads of regular cheese, either.

If you’re only having a small bit here and there, it’s not overly bad for you, but it’s still not as healthy as ‘real’ cheese. That said, if you have any worries about nutrition, you should seek a nutritionist, as I am not qualified to give you advice.

Summary

Well, that brings us to an end of the best 7 substitutions for Velveeta cheese. We’ve covered 7 wonderful kinds of cheese, that we hope that you will enjoy.

Feel free to comment and share your favorite cheeses, I’d love to know what you think is best.

Thanks for reading!

The 7 Best Velveeta Cheese Substitutes

0 from 0 votes

Whether you’re using cheese in a recipe, or you like a slice of cheese and crackers in the evening, cheese plays a huge role in the kitchen.

Ingredients

  • Mild Cheddar Cheese

  • Swiss Cheese

  • Sharp Cheddar Cheese

  • Pepper Jack

  • Cheez Whiz

  • Eden Cheese

  • American Cheese

Directions

  • Decided on what substitute you need
  • Pick a substitute from the list above
  • Read what you need to substitute with
  • Create the recipe and enjoy

Recipe Video

Jess Smith