Skip to Content

6 Perfect Substitutes For Sweetened Condensed Milk For Your Sweet Recipes

Does your recipe call for sweetened condensed milk, and you’ve only just discovered that you have run out? Don’t have time to dash to your local grocery store?

Don’t panic, because there are actually a number of awesome alternatives that you can depend on to get the job done, and still deliver that sweet taste that some of your recipes will require! 

But what are these superb substitutes for sweetened condensed milk? How do they manage to make for such good substitutes, and how do you actually use them? If you’ve ever wondered this yourself, then you have come to the right place.

6 Substitutes For Sweetened Condensed Milk For Your Sweet Recipes

So why not read on below, and get started in finding out what condensed milk substitutes you can use in your recipes right now?

1. Heavy Cream

Heavy cream is actually incredibly similar to condensed milk in its purest form, thanks to the fact that it has a lower water content, and thus has a perfect creaminess that is very similar. 

Heavy cream can easily substitute for condensed milk in basically every situation, and still results in totally perfect recipes every time.

However, in order to make it a truly perfect substitute for sweetened condensed milk, you will want to make sure to add some sugar to the mix!

How To Substitute

If you’re planning to use heavy cream as a substitute for condensed milk, you can luckily make use of the 1:1 ratio, making it incredibly easy to do. For every cup of condensed milk that you need, simply take a cup of heavy cream.

2. Whole Milk

If you find that you have run out of condensed milk, but you have plenty of whole milk, then you are in luck, because you can actually easily create your own condensed milk, by following the right process. 

Making your own condensed milk from whole milk is actually surprisingly easy, and by following the right process, and adding some of your own sugar, you can very easily create sweetened condensed milk that is unmistakable from the real thing!

How To Substitute

In order to create your own condensed milk, start by measuring out two cups of whole milk, place it atop your stove, and allow it to simmer, on low heat unless it starts thickening and become just like condensed milk.

3. Powdered Milk

If you find that you have run out of not only condensed milk, but also standard whole milk, don’t fret, because you can also make use of powdered milk which you likely have in your pantry, and that is designed to last a very long time. 

Powdered milk makes for a perfect substitute for condensed milk because you can ensure that you always have it around in your kitchen, ready for use when you need a replacement for condensed milk. 

How To Substitute

In order to use powdered milk as a substitute for condensed milk, you will first need to turn it into actual milk. For 1 cup of milk, take 1 and ⅓ cups of powdered milk, and then mix it with ⅓ cup of hot water with a bit of fat. Slowly, the milk will begin to thicken, so keep stirring until it becomes the right consistency.

4. Cream Of Coconut

If you want a vegan alternative to condensed milk, then this is the perfect option. In fact, this is also a fantastic option if you want to inject a little bit of exotic flavor into any recipes you make. 

Cream of coconut is naturally very sweet and is very often used to sweeten up numerous drinks and foods, especially summertime favorites like Pina Coladas.

Luckily, cream of coconut is easy to find in your local grocery store, and can often be found in the world-foods aisle. 

However, you should make sure to only pick up cream of coconut, instead of coconut cream, as they are actually entirely different, and often get confused for one another. 

6 Substitutes For Sweetened Condensed Milk For Your Sweet Recipes (1)

How To Substitute

Luckily, substituting cream of coconut for condensed milk is very easy, because cream of coconut is already quite thick. Simply substitute it using the 1:1 ratio. So, for every cup of condensed milk, simply add a cup of cream of coconut!

RELATED: 6 Excellent Substitutes For Half And Half Milk

5. Coconut Milk

Similar to cream of coconut, using coconut milk makes for a perfect solution when you find yourself running out of condensed milk.

Once again, you should make sure that coconut milk is appropriate for whatever recipe you are following, as it will naturally make the end result taste very coconutty.

However, this can easily elevate some very standard sweet recipes, to create exotic varieties that will delight your taste buds. 

How To Substitute

Start by taking 2 cups of coconut milk for every cup of condensed milk, and then begin reducing it by slowly stirring it on a low heat on your kitchen stove to thicken and simply mix in ⅔ of a cup of sugar, which will cause the milk to sweeten up a lot, making it a perfect substitute.

6. Almond Milk

Using almond milk as a stand-in for sweetened condensed milk is another fantastic solution, as it is naturally quite thick, and is already very sweet.

As well as this, you can also use it to add a little bit of flavor to your resulting dish. Almond milk has a very creamy and nutty taste that can make certain dishes taste even better.

However, once again you should make sure that it is appropriate, as it may not always mix perfectly with every recipe. 

Almond milk is also incredibly low in calories, despite being so decadently thick, so it can also act as a very healthy substitute! 

How To Substitute

In order to substitute almond milk for sweetened condensed milk, you are first going to need to reduce it to condense.Two cups of almond milk, for every cup of condensed milk into a pan and allowing it to simmer over low heat until it thickens and you will eventually be left with around a cup of milk left over.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Can I Use In Place Of Sweetened Condensed Milk?

An easy substitution for sweetened condensed milk is unsweetened coconut milk, which you will find in most grocery stores. It comes in a can and is similar in consistency to condensed milk. To use it, add 1/2 cup of unsweetened coconut milk to 1 cup of unsweetened almond milk and 1/2 teaspoon of vanilla extract.

Can You Substitute Milk For Sweetened Condensed Milk?

No, it won’t be an excellent decision to substitute milk for sweetened condensed milk since it is prepared with some flavoring agents. If you need to replace it, go for evaporated milk with sugar. It will be the best choice which you can opt for.

Can I Use Honey Instead Of Condensed Milk?

Of course, we can use substitute honey for condensed milk. It is a natural sweetener and a healthy option to replace the unhealthy sugar content in your dish. The best thing about honey is that it doesn’t get spoiled like condensed milk.

Can You Substitute Coconut Cream For Sweetened Condensed Milk?

The answer is yes. Coconut cream is a versatile and flavorful dairy product made from the meat of a mature coconut that you can substitute for condensed milk in various recipes. Coconut cream is often used in sweet and savory dishes and gives your dishes a tropical flavor.

Can Yogurt Be A Substitute For Condensed Milk?

Some might wonder if it is possible to substitute condensed milk with yogurt. This question is more challenging to answer than you might think, as the two are very different in taste and texture. For example, condensed milk is much thicker, sweeter, and denser than yogurt. However, one thing that might help is that you can use a combination of the two to create a sauce.

6 Substitutes For Sweetened Condensed Milk For Your Sweet Recipes

5 from 7 votes
Prep time

5

minutes
Cooking time

40

minutes
Total time

45

minutes

Sometimes a recipe calls for sweetened condensed milk, and it’s already too late before you realize that you have run out! But what can you use instead?

Ingredients

  • Heavy Cream

  • Whole Milk

  • Powdered Milk

  • Cream Of Coconut

  • Coconut Milk

  • Almond Milk

Directions

  • Choose your favorite substitute from the list given above
  • Follow the directions given in the recipe after having substituted the ingredient in the correct ratio

Recipe Video

Jess Smith

byronizes

Monday 5th of September 2022

Ιt's amazing to pay a visit this website and reading the views of all cοlleagᥙes about this parаgrapһ, while I am also zealous of getting experience.

francisco

Tuesday 23rd of August 2022

It's actually a cool аnd useful piece of infoгmation. I am satisfieⅾ that you simpⅼy shared this helpful information with us. Please stay us up to date like this. Thanks for sһaring.