10 Best Maple Syrup Alternatives

Breakfast may be a meal that brings to mind images of crispy bacon and waffles or fried eggs served with a side of toast. But did you know that breakfast can also be extremely beneficial for your physical and mental health?

10 Best Maple Syrup Alternatives

Not only can a nutritious breakfast give us the energy we need to get through the day, but it can also keep us full and nourished until lunch, giving us plenty of time to finish our work and chores.

These days, one of the most popular breakfast dishes is pancakes, which are known for their sweet taste and versatile nature.

While you can add countless toppings to your morning pancakes, one of the best things to use is maple syrup, which has fast become one of the world’s most cherished breakfast condiments.

However, this does not mean that maple syrup does not come with its setbacks, as even a large bottle of the sugary treat can quickly run out in a busy household.

So if you want to know how you can combat this problem, then you have come to the right place.

In the following article, we are going to cover the top 10 best maple syrup alternatives currently available on the market, so that you can choose the best substitute for your breakfast pancakes.

Not only are our choices sweet and delicious, but they are also cheap, easy to find and may even be waiting in your kitchen cupboard. So if you want to save breakfast, we have everything you need to get started…

Overview

If you are in a rush and don’t have the time to read the whole article, then we have provided a condensed version of our list in the section below:

  1. Honey
  2. Golden syrup
  3. White Sugar Syrup
  4. Molasses
  5. Brown Sugar Syrup
  6. Agave Nectar
  7. Corn Syrup
  8. Coconut Nectar
  9. Caramel Syrup
  10. Brown Rice Syrup

If you want to know more about each of our choices, then we have provided a more detailed look at maple syrup alternatives in the following guide.

10 Best Maple Syrup Alternatives

Just because you have run out of maple syrup, this doesn’t mean that you can’t enjoy a delicious plate of morning pancakes.

In fact, there are plenty of alternatives that you can use to smother your breakfast with some much-needed sweetness.

Fortunately, most of these products are condiments that can already be found in your house, which means you probably won’t have to spend too much time and money to find the best one.

Now let’s get started…

Honey

If you run out of maple syrup, then the next best thing to use is honey. Not only because both maple syrup and honey are similar, but because they are both sweet and natural in their production.

Beyond this, one of the best things about honey is that it can be found in kitchen cabinets across the country, as it remains a popular ingredient in various recipes, from cakes to sweet and sour dishes.

While it is recommended that you use a ratio of 1:1 when substituting honey, you can always adjust this measure and use a cup of honey for every ⅔ of maple syrup.

However, when it comes to your morning pancakes, you can use as much honey as you want.

Of course, honey is different from maple syrup in terms of flavour and consistency, as it is much thicker and offers a more distinctive floral taste.

So when it comes to using honey as a substitute for maple syrup, these are things that you need to consider, especially when it comes to cooking.

Golden Syrup

Because maple syrup often features as a prominent ingredient in countless recipes, it is always advisable to have an alternative close to hand, which is why we recommend purchasing a bottle of golden syrup in case of emergencies.

While similar to maple syrup, this condiment sports a unique buttery taste, which can be adjusted to infuse your cooking with a variety of creative flavours.

Despite its buttery taste, golden syrup does not contain any butter and instead features a combination of sugar, citric acid and water.

Due to its thick consistency, we recommend using the required amount needed when making desserts or baked goods, otherwise, you could risk ruining the recipe that you need the syrup for.

White Sugar Syrup

Sugar can be used for a variety of different purposes, especially when it comes to the kitchen, which is why it can make an amazing alternative to using maple syrup.

One of the best ways to use sugar as a substitute is by purchasing a white sugar syrup, which is known to be less sweet than maple syrup and thicker in its consistency.

For this reason, you should only use a cup of white sugar syrup for every ⅔ cup of maple syrup, although this may vary depending on the type of recipe that you are using.

However, it is important to note that you will also need to decrease the other liquid ingredients being used in the dish.

But perhaps one of the best things about white sugar syrup is that it can be made from home and is perfectly suitable for cocktails and cakes.

Molasses

Perhaps one of the best alternatives for maple syrup is molasses, as it can be used in countless recipes that call for maple syrup as the main ingredient.

Defined by its sweet and aromatic taste, molasses can be used to infuse your food with a distinctive smoky flavour, making it a popular substitute among passionate cooks.

Beyond this, molasses can also be purchased in different varieties, with light and dark molasses being the two most popular options. However, it is important to remember that the darker the molasses the stronger it will be.

When using molasses, you will need to substitute one cup for one cup of maple syrup, especially when it comes to making candies and desserts.

Brown Sugar Syrup

Brown Sugar Syrup

If you want to know how you can make your own maple syrup alternative, then you have come to the right place. All you have to do is mix together some brown sugar, water and vanilla to produce a delicious brown sugar syrup.

While it tastes delicious on pancakes, this syrup particularly excels when used to make cakes, desserts and baked goods.

Fortunately, this syrup can be kept in the refrigerator for up to a month and can be easily remade whenever you discover that the maple syrup is running low.

Agave Nectar

Another great way to substitute maple syrup is by using agave nectar, which is a sweet syrup that is similar to both honey and maple syrup.

Because of this, it makes a great alternative when cooking countless dishes and can even be used to improve the flavour of your work.

While the nectar is known for its bitter aftertaste, it still makes a great sweetener in desserts and baked goods, with the bitterness even adding its own unique flair.

However, it should be noted that agave nectar is very different in its consistency and therefore should be used accordingly when making the swap.

Corn Syrup

Considered one of the most important ingredients in American cuisine, corn syrup makes a great alternative to maple syrup, as it is a sweet and versatile product.

While the syrup can be very powerful, it can also be used in countless recipes and can even be purchased in different strengths and colours.

Distinguished by its rich caramel flavour, this syrup can work wonders when added to desserts and candies, although it has also been featured in various cocktail recipes.

The syrup is also known to add volume and should be used with a 1:1 ratio.

Coconut Nectar

As we previously mentioned, coconut nectar can also be used as a refreshing alternative to maple syrup, as both products are similar in their natural qualities and caramel flavour.

Coconut nectar can also be used in a variety of delicious recipes and is considered a key ingredient in numerous Asian cuisines. However, you will need to adjust the quantity when using this syrup as a substitute.

Caramel Syrup

If there is a condiment that closely resembles maple syrup its caramel syrup, with both products being favoured for their rich flavour and sweetness.

Thanks to its hints of caramel, this syrup is commonly used as an alternative to maple syrup and tastes great on pancakes and ice cream.

Made from brown sugar that has been allowed to caramelize, this syrup can be used to make cakes and desserts, although you will still need to adjust the quantity to suit the recipe you are making.

Brown Rice Syrup

Known for its mild and nutty flavour, brown rice syrup makes for a good maple syrup substitute due to its honey-like nature, which makes it perfect for baking cakes and candies.

Like maple syrup, this product is sweet and thick, with the syrup often being used as a refreshing addition to drinks and cocktails.

How To Make Homemade Maple Syrup

Of course, the best alternative to maple syrup is your own homemade concoction, which can be whipped up using some simple and cheap ingredients.

So if you want to know how you can make this homemade syrup for yourself, we have everything you need down below:

Ingredients

  • Water
  • Honey
  • Sugar
  • Vanilla extract
  • Maple extract

Method

  1. Boil the water, honey and sugar together.
  2. Place the ingredients into a pot or saucepan and set it over medium heat for 8-10 minutes.
  3. While the mixture simmers, remember to continue stirring the ingredients until they have blended together.
  4. Remove the mixture from the stove and add the vanilla and maple extracts.
  5. Stir the ingredients together and allow the mixture to rest for 5-7 minutes.
  6. Pour the mixture into a jug or container and you will have a delicious maple syrup that your whole family will enjoy!
Jess Smith
Latest posts by Jess Smith (see all)