Skip to Content

21 Mouth-Watering Bagel Toppings That You Will Love Making

Some bagel toppings you should try are sun-dried tomato tapenade, homemade chia jam and nut butter, bacon and avocado breakfast bagel, Greek yogurt bagels with Asiago, etc. 

Bagel originated from Poland’s Jewish communities and has been around for over a hundred years. The chewiness of the bagel is a result of boiling the bagels.

Usually, bagels are plain, and you will be the one to decide what toppings to add to your bagel. 

Once you know the fantastic, delicious bagel toppings, you will have bagels for all your meals.

Quick Table: Fantastic Top 20 Bagel Toppings

RecipesCalories Per ServingPreparation Time
Greek yogurt bagels with Asiago177 20 Minutes
Homemade chia jam and nut butter38 30 Minutes
Cinna-maple coconut almond butter191 20 Minutes
Toasted Tuna Everything bagels577 10 Minutes
New York-style blueberry bagels221 2 Hours 30 Minutes
Gingerbread bagels336 3 Hours
Cinnamon crunch bagels249 1 Hour 30 Minutes
Bacon egg and avocado breakfast bagel313 5 Minutes
Bagel bites in the air fryer190 6 Minutes
Homemade bagel chips102 10 Minutes
Sun-dried tomato tapenade 39 20 Minutes
Smoked salmon bagel577 10 Minutes
Goddess Curry chicken salad358 15 Minutes
Toasted Everything bagel seasoning37 2 Minutes
Avocado egg salad265 10 Minutes
Turkey apple cheddar bagel melts350 10 Minutes
Vegan breakfast bagel sandwich445 5 Minutes
Nutella oatmeal with sliced bananas470 5 Minutes
Cranberry orange bagels197 1 Hour 30 Minutes
French toast bagels296 2 Hours
Sausage egg and cheese bagel560 5 Minutes

1. Greek Yogurt Bagels With Asiago

Greek yogurt bagels with Asiago are the perfect cheesy version of bagels that require few ingredients to prepare.

You will not have trouble making them since they are super easy and fast. One of the main ingredients in making these delicacies is self-rising flour. 

If you do not have it or can’t find it at the store, you can make it yourself home. You can easily make it by combining baking powder, all-purpose flour, and salt. 

The other ingredients you will need are egg, nonfat plain Greek yogurt, and shredded asiago cheese.

After the second day, it would be best to toast them before eating them. After toasting, you can spread butter on it or make an egg sandwich.

Calories Per Serving: 177

Preparation Time: 20 Minutes

2. Homemade Chia Jam And Nut Butter

Homemade chia jam and nut butter are a wholesome topping for your bagel. It is a fun way to bring back some excitement to breakfast time. Why wouldn’t you try to make this tasty topping, yet it is simple and fast?

The best part of this topping is you get to make it more natural and nutritious by including fresh fruits and chia. 

The first thing you should do is decide what nut or fruit you want to choose. You can go with strawberries, grapes, peanuts, and almonds for a perfect variation of the spreads.

If you want the creamiest nut butter, you should ensure that your butter has no skin.You can add coconut oil to help with the texture and honey to keep things smooth. Adding chia seeds to the whole mixture will thicken it since it swells after some time.

Once your chia jam and nut butter are ready, you can spread them to your bagel and enjoy your delightful breakfast accompanied by hot coffee.  

Calories Per Serving: 38

Preparation Time: 30 Minutes

3. Cinna-Maple Coconut Almond Butter

This fantastic, delicious topping came from the idea that apple and nut butter is a perfect combination.

Spreading Cinna-maple coconut almond butter to your bagel makes it a perfect vegan breakfast. You will have to use fresh ripe apples for the best results. 

The ingredients for this recipe are raw almonds, a few pinches of cinnamon, maple syrup, sea salt, and virgin coconut oil.

Once you finish making your Cinna-maple coconut almond butter using a blender, you will slather it on your gluten-free bagel and serve it alongside fresh ripe apples. 

Calories Per Serving: 191

Preparation Time: 20 Minutes

4. Toasted Tuna Everything Bagels

For those evenings that you want a light dinner in a few minutes, Toasted Tuna Everything bagels are the dish to prepare.

You will get amused by how incredibly these delicacies are easy to make. Is there a better way to enjoy your bagel than slathering it with tuna salad? 

The ingredients for making tuna salad are Albacore tuna, lemon juice, yellow onion, celery, miracle whip, lemon juice, dill weed, and pepper. This delicacy will go well with a glass of wine or any of your favorite fruit juice. 

Calories Per Serving: 577

Preparation Time: 10 Minutes

5. New York-Style Blueberry Bagels

Making bagels at home is economical and allows you to make various bagels. One of the bagels you should try is New York-style blueberry bagels. These bagels consist of blueberry toppings baked together with the bagel itself.

These bagels are chewy, authentic, delicious, and easy to make from scratch. You can have them plain or roasted and add cream cheese for more flavor. 

Once you mix your blueberries with your dough, the dough will look purple. It would be best to boil them first to ensure they get a chewy and authentic texture. 

After boiling them, you will drain them and then bake them. To prepare this recipe, you will need dry yeast, blueberries, all-purpose flour, sugar, salt, and warm water. 

Calories Per Serving: 221

Preparation Time: 2 Hours 30 Minutes

RELATED: 10 Best Hawaiian Breakfast Recipes

6. Gingerbread Bagels

These chewy and delicious bagels are easy to make and perfect for a holiday treat. You can enjoy them for breakfast, lunch, dinner, or dessert. 

These gingerbread bagels contain molasses and traditional gingerbread spices. Once you make your dough, it would be best to cover your dough and let it rise in a warm spot once you make it. 

The ingredients for this recipe are sugar, cinnamon, ginger, all-purpose flour, warm milk, active instant yeast, molasses, brown sugar, nutmeg, allspice, and salt.

You will best enjoy your gingerbread bagels when served with hot coffee or tea and spreading cream cheese on them. 

Calories Per Serving: 336 

Preparation Time: 3 Hours

7. Cinnamon Crunch Bagels

Cinnamon crunch bagels are a tasty breakfast treat with a cinnamon-sugar crunchy top. The cinnamon-sugar coating on top of the bagel is crisp as it bakes, giving the bagel a crispy, chewy, and delicious taste. 

Unlike blueberry and gingerbread bagels, when making cinnamon crunch bagels., you will not mix the cinnamon with your dough. 

Instead, you will make the dough alone, boil it, and sprinkle the cinnamon topping mixture. Afterward, it is when you will bake your bagel with the cinnamon crunch on top. 

The ingredients for making cinnamon crunch bagels are active dry yeast, granulated white sugar, all-purpose flour, cinnamon, warm water, salt, and brown sugar

Calories Per Serving: 249

Preparation Time: 1 Hour 30 Minutes

8. Bacon Egg And Avocado Breakfast Bagel

It is easy to make this delicious breakfast treat, full of flavor and filling. Starting your day with this mouth-watering treat will ensure you have a delightful day. 

This delicacy contains fluffy scrambled eggs, cream cheese, tomato slices, creamy garlic avocado mash, chewy bagel, and crispy bacon. 

If you are not a fan of bacon, you can replace it with ham or turkey. You can also have it for brunch or dinner.

If you want some add-ins to your bagel for more flavor, you can add roasted red peppers, sauteed mushrooms, caramelized onions, sauteed spinach, or any jam flavor. 

Calories Per Serving: 313

Preparation Time: 5 Minutes

9. Bagel Bites In The Air Fryer

If you want a snack that your whole family will love, bagel bites in the air fryer should be your first choice. They are a perfect topping that you can sandwich between your bagels. 

The good thing about them is that they are super easy and will not take much of your time. 

You will cook your bagel bites for 182C for 5-6 minutes. The only ingredient you will need is bagel bites which you will buy from a store. 

This delicacy is versatile since you can have it for breakfast, dinner, or lunch. You can serve it alongside an avocado salad. 

Calories Per Serving: 190

Preparation Time: 6 Minutes

10. Homemade Bagel Chips

Bagel chips are the perfect snack for any occasion since it is a crowd pleasers and quick to prepare. It is crunchy and crispy and can be ready in less than twenty minutes. 

You will slice a bagel in half and cut it into strips when making this delicacy. Then, brush it with olive oil and bake until brown and crisp. 

For more flavor, sprinkle favorite seasonings, like BBQ or Montreal steak seasoning. You can enjoy bagel chips by dipping them in soup or creamy dips. This recipe will only need bagels, olive oil, seasoning, and salt. 

Calories Per Serving: 102

Preparation Time: 10 Minutes

RELATED: 15 Breakfast Sides (+ Easy Recipes)

11. Sun-Dried Tomato Tapenade

Are you a fan of combining anchovies, olives, and capers? These delicious tomato tapenade bagels(sun-dried) will drive you crazy if you are.

Tapenade happens to be a savory paste that contains anchovy filets, mixed olives, capers, garlic, olive oil, and lemon juice. It is the number one topping you should consider putting on your bagel.

People used mortar and pestle in the past, but you can now mix everything using a food processor, which is super easy. 

Adding sun-dried tomatoes to the mixture will result in a richly flavorful spread that will go well with your bagel. 

Calories Per Serving: 39

Preparation Time: 20 Minutes

12. Smoked Salmon Bagel

If you want a dish with deliciousness in every bite, try a smoked salmon bagel. It is full of flavors, and it is easy to make. It is perfect for serving on a lazy Sunday morning. 

For this recipe, you will need cream cheese, seasoning, lemon juice, smoked salmon, dill, bagel, and toppings like avocado, eggs, or tomatoes. 

It would be best to toast your bagels since it will add more texture and deliciousness.

In addition, you should soften the cream cheese before combining it to ensure all the ingredients mix quickly and evenly. For better quality, you should use fresh ingredients. 

Calories Per Serving: 577

Preparation Time: 10 Minutes

13. Goddess Curry Chicken Salad

What better way to enjoy your bagel than topping it with curry chicken salad? Curry chicken salad is super delicious, containing loads of spiced chicken, herbs, golden raisins, Greek yogurt, and pistachios. 

The difference between this Goddess curry chicken salad and the regular one is that Goddess curry chicken salad lacks fruits and has no mayo. 

To prepare this delicacy, you will need honey, pistachios, chicken breast, cilantro, garlic powder, onion, golden raisins, olive oil, Greek yogurt, curry powder, salt, and pepper.

 Enjoying your bagel with this Goddess curry chicken salad accompanying it with a glass of wine would be best. 

Calories Per Serving: 358

Preparation Time: 15 Minutes

14. Toasted Everything Bagel Seasoning

What you will love about toasted bagel seasoning is that it is versatile. You can top it to anything you want, including bagels. 

If you want your toasted everything bagel seasoning to have more flavor and get the most out of it, ensure you toast it in a skillet. Once you taste this seasoning, you will never buy the store-bought blends. 

The ingredients you will need to prepare your Toasted Everything bagel seasoning are poppy seeds, dried minced garlic, sesame seeds, sea salt, dried minced onion, and red pepper flakes.

 You can serve your delicious bagel with Toasted Everything bagel seasoning with roasted steak and hot sauce. 

Calories Per Serving: 37

Preparation Time: 2 Minutes

15. Avocado Egg Salad

Who doesn’t love egg salad? Imagine using avocado for the base of your egg salad instead of mayonnaise. The combination is super delicious, and you won’t stop eating it once you taste it. 

Slathering your avocado egg salad on your bagel is a match made in heaven. You will have a silky-smooth, creamy-dreamy, delicious avocado egg salad bagel that will not disappoint. 

If you want to zip in your bagel, you should add lemon juice. If you want to take your avocado egg salad bagel to the next level, add everything bagel seasoning. 

It is beyond good, and it is healthy. You will need avocados, dill, lemon juice, eggs, parsley, salt, and olive oil. 

Calories Per Serving: 265

Preparation Time: 10 Minutes

RELATED: 16 Bagel Toppings For Breakfast, Lunch, And Dinner

16. Turkey Apple Cheddar Bagel Melts

Have you ever thought of making a lunch plate that consists of sliced turkey, cheddar, and apples? This delicious turkey apple cheddar bagel melts all that onto a toasty mouth-watering bagel. 

If you want to add fantastic color and flavor to your delicious open-faced bagel sandwich, you will throw some micro-greens into your bagel. 

The sweet taste you will get when you bite this mouth-watering crispy, and chewy bagel is one to die for. You will not need a side dish to accompany your bagel, only a glass of wine.

To prepare this recipe, you will require bagels, turkey breast, crisp honey apples, micro-greens, cheddar cheese, and Dijon mustard. 

Calories Per Serving: 350

Preparation Time: 10 Minutes

17. Vegan Breakfast Bagel Sandwich

This bagel sandwich is a delicious dish that contains toppings of fluffy plant-based egg, sliced tomatoes, dairy-free cheese, and smashed avocado. 

This mouth-watering sandwich is simple and quick to prepare, so you will want to prepare it every morning. 

Your delicious vegan breakfast bagel sandwich will go well with a hot cup of coffee or tea.

You can decide to add as many veggies as you want but ensure that you do not overload your bagel. It is the perfect dish you can serve as dessert after a party. 

Calories Per Serving: 445

Preparation Time: 5 Minutes

18. Nutella Oatmeal With Sliced Bananas

Another exciting topping you should consider for your bagel is Nutella oatmeal with sliced bananas. In this recipe, the Nutella melts into a warm batch of stovetop oatmeal resulting in a creamy yummy recipe

When you add sliced fresh bananas to the mixture, you will have a mouth-watering topping that will go perfectly with your bagel. 

The ingredients needed to make this Nutella oatmeal are Nutella, milk, old-fashioned oats, sliced banana, kosher salt, and dark brown sugar. If you do not have Nutella, peanut butter can also work. 

Calories Per Serving: 470

Preparation Time: 5 Minutes

19. Cranberry Orange Bagels

Cranberry orange bagels are delicious bagels infused with cranberries and orange zest. The good thing about these bagels is that they are simple to prepare. 

However, you must be patient since you must wait for the dough to rise before baking it. Cranberry orange bagels are filled with the mouth-watering flavor of grated orange peel and dried cranberries. 

Mix your dough with the dried cranberries, orange peel, salt, and brown sugar in one bowl. After that, you will boil and then bake until they turn golden brown and chewy on the outside. 

You will need cornmeal, warm water, all-purpose flour, dried cranberries, brown sugar, granulated sugar, grated orange peel, egg, active dry yeast, and salt. 

Calories Per Serving: 197

Preparation Time: 1 Hour 30 Minutes

20. French Toast Bagels

Have you ever found yourself in a dilemma of choosing between French toast or bagels for breakfast?

You can enjoy both in one dish by preparing French toast bagels. They are soft, infused with maple, and topped with a crunchy cinnamon-sugar mixture

The delicious French toast bagels taste like French toast in bagel form. What you will love about French toast bagels is that it is effortless to make. 

For this recipe, you will need brown sugar, cinnamon, vanilla extract, salt, warm water, maple syrup, active dry yeast, granulated sugar, and eggs. Your delightful French toast bagels will go well with hot sauce.

Calories Per Serving: 296

Preparation Time: 2 Hours

RELATED: 10 Easy And Healthy Breakfast Ideas For School Kids

21. Sausage Egg And Cheese Bagel

If there is something that will get you excited getting out of your bed, it is sausage egg and cheese bagel.

This toasty bagel contains sausage, egg, veggie scramble, and melted cheese. You can add crispy bacon if you want to add more crispiness to your bagel. 

You can also spice it up by adding hot sauce or sriracha. It would be best if you didn’t make these bagels ahead of time since they are best when served immediately. 

Prepare your favorite delicious hot coffee, and you will be good to go. 

Calories Per Serving: 560

Preparation Time: 5 Minutes

Frequently Asked Questions

How Many Calories Are In A Plain Bagel?

Bagel is a delicious dish that you can add any topping you want. In addition, it is also healthy since it does not have many calories. A plain bagel has approximately 250 calories. However, the more toppings you add, the more calories will be. 

What Is Good On A Bagel For Breakfast?

Breakfast is an important meal since it is the one that will fuel you for the entire day. Therefore, you need a heavy breakfast that is healthy and delicious. 

A bagel for breakfast is fantastic, but you need the right toppings. You can add toppings like salmon, chicken, steak, or vegetables for a healthy breakfast. 

How Do You Keep Toppings On Bagels?

To make the toppings on your bagels perfectly hold, you should use egg wash. You will brush your bagels with beaten egg white before putting your toppings. Your bagel will look shinier, and they will hold the toppings better.

21 Mouth-Watering Bagel Toppings That You Will Love Making

You can also spice it up by adding hot sauce or sriracha. It would be best if you didn’t make these bagels ahead of time since they are best when served immediately. 


  • Pick a recipe from the list above
  • Click the recipe name and visit the website
  • Collect the ingredients and cook the food
  • Enjoy – don’t forget to leave a review

Recipe Video

Jess Smith