Skip to Content

What Does Mayo Taste Like And Can You Make Homemade Versions?

Mayo or mayonnaise is a rich and creamy topping used in many recipes. It is one of the most popular toppings in the world due to its sharp taste and long-term life.

Mayo’s taste is typically slightly sour but dense and mixes many ingredients to produce a very lush taste.

If you’re interested in using mayo, it is important to know several important facts about it. For example, knowing how it is made and its varieties can help you when shopping.

Understanding general mayo taste can also help you make various meals with this ingredient.

In this article, we’ll check out a typical mayo taste profile, give you mayo’s nutritional value, and provide three DIY recipes.

We’ll also discuss other important facts about mayonnaise, such as how it looks, how to serve it, and how it compares to a popular competitor.

What Is Mayo?

Mayo Taste

Mayo is a thick and creamy sauce typically served cold on sandwiches, salads, burgers, French fries, and other dishes. It is made primarily of oil, egg yolk, vinegar, or lemon juice.

Most mayos are either nearly white or slightly yellow, depending on the brand or variety. Some companies do make eggless varieties, as well as limited-dairy options that may suit other people’s dietary needs.

The earliest mayo recipes used ingredients like aspic, oil, and Allemade, along with vinegar, pepper, and salt. Modern mayo is a variation of various recipes and is typically easy to find in most grocery stores.

A variation of mayo, called Miracle Whip, is also available. We’ll discuss Miracle Whip later because of its unique place in the mayo world.

What Taste Does Mayo Describe?

Mayo Taste

Mayo has a slightly sour taste that is similar to sour cream, Greek yogurt, or pesto sauce. The taste is typically quite mild, though more potent varieties are available.

Variations like vegan, olive oil, and reduced-fat mayo have slightly blander or differing tastes. That’s because they use different ingredients to produce a healthier and less fat-dense taste that should go well on many diets.

What Does Mayo Look Like?

Mayo Taste

Mayo is usually white or pale yellow and looks like a sauce. Its thick texture requires it to be scooped with a spoon or spread with a knife. Some people may compare mayo to a body cream or hair lotion, based on its overall density.

Mayo may easily stain some clothes if it gets on their fibers and soaks too much into their overall texture.

What Texture Does Mayo Have?

Mayo has a fairly dense and thick texture that means it typically cannot be poured directly from the serving jar. Instead, you have to spread it with a knife to ensure that it goes on your bread or salad evenly.

Spreading your mayo helps to decrease its density and make it more palpable, as thick dollops may be a little hard for some peoples’ tongues to accept.

Types Of Mayo

Mayo Taste

Mayo comes in many types from many manufacturers. The basic type includes a full-fat content that makes it tastier but less healthy.

Low-fat or organic alternatives eliminate high-fat and preservatives (like salt) to make them healthier and easier to tolerate. Some manufacturers make various mayo recipes that you can also make at home, such as

  • Basil Mayo
  • Dill Mayo
  • Caper Mayo
  • Chive Mayo
  • Herb Mayo
  • Pesto Aioli
  • Ranch Mayo
  • Black Pepper Mayo
  • Chipotle Mayo
  • Sriracha Mayo
  • Ginger-Sesame Mayo
  • Pecan Mayo

Later on, we’ll highlight how you can make a basic mayo recipe to produce this topping at home. In a later section, we’ll discuss three alternative recipes that either increase the taste or improve the health of your mayo.

Try these variations if you get sick of store-bought mayo or when you want something a little different and fun for your diet.

Where Does Mayo Come From?

Mayo seems to have originated in France around 1806, though it may also have come from Spain and other nearby areas. The confusion about this topping comes from mixed historical references to it throughout Europe.

It definitely comes from European sources and could be based on an ancient remoulade, an emulsified recipe that used similar items to produce a rich and diverse topping.

Is Mayo Healthy? Or Dangers Of Eating Mayo?

Mayo is not a particularly healthy topping because it is high in fat and very calorie dense. It also lacks significant vitamins and minerals. It does have a few trace elements in it that are healthy, such as:

  • Vitamin A: 70 IU or 2% of your daily intake
  • Vitamin B-12: 0.12 ug or 2% of your daily intake
  • Vitamin E: 2.19 milligrams or 15% of your daily intake
  • Vitamin K: 53.7 ug or 67% of your daily intake

Note that mayo has a very high concentration of sodium. Brands may have between 800 to 1,000 milligrams of sodium, which is between 53-60% of your daily intake.

Making mayo at home can help you cut back on this sodium intake by limiting how much salt you add.

RELATED: 10 Of The Best Alternatives To Chinese Five-Spice To Use In Your Cooking!

How Do You Eat Mayo?

Mayo is typically eaten as a topping or ingredient in meals and not by itself. For example, you can eat mayo as a/an:

  • Topping on various meat-based sandwiches
  • Dip for some types of vegetables, though this is rare
  • Ingredient in baking several types of foods
  • Element for various other types of dips
  • Topping on a salad when blended with salad dressing

Mayo is typically measured in teaspoons, meaning that your calories and nutrients vary depending on how much you add. Try to keep your servings as low as possible to health concerns.

For example, adding one tablespoon instead of two cuts the fat and calories by half while not heavily affecting your meal’s taste.

How Can I Store Mayo?

Mayo can be stored at room temperature for 2-8 hours but is best stored in your refrigerator. It can be stored as long as its shelf life is recommended, which is usually between 2-3 months.

Unopened mayonnaise can be stored in your uncooled pantry as long as its expiration date, though all opened mayonnaise should be refrigerated.

Can You Freeze Mayo?

Mayonnaise can be frozen for several months, as long as you carefully mix the ingredients before freezing. When thawing it, leave it in the sink for a few hours or in your refrigerator overnight.

Try to use your mayo within 2-3 months to ensure that you don’t end up with bad mayo that could cause food poisoning and other illnesses.

How To Tell If Mayo Is Bad?

There are several ways you can tell if mayo has gone bad, including

  • Separating ingredients, with fluid floating on the solid top
  • Discoloration of the mayo’s white or yellow texture
  • A sharp smell that differs heavily from mayo’s normally bland odor
  • Sour tastes that cause an upset stomach
  • Mold growing on the top of the mayo

Don’t risk eating bad mayo but instead just throw it away immediately. You don’t have to do anything special to throw away bad mayo as long as you keep the lid closely shut.

Note that you may want to throw out your garbage bag quickly before the mayo makes it start to smell bad.

How Can I Pick Up Mayo In A Grocery Store?

Mayo is easily available in just about any supermarket in your town. You typically find it in the condiments aisle next to salad dressings and other toppings.

Various sizes may be available, such as large jars and even squeezable plastic containers. This latter type of mayo is the easiest to spread on sandwiches but may be harder to measure for baking recipes.

Mayo Vs. Miracle Whip

Miracle Whip uses the same ingredients as mayo but adds sugar, water, and spices to create a sweeter mix. Miracle Whip also has half the calories, which is a miracle indeed.

It can be considered a healthier alternative to traditional mayo, though some may not like the extra sugar it contains (two grams).

As a result, you can use Miracle Whip as an ingredient in various recipes and as a topping for sandwiches. It may be an easier choice for pickier children who do not like mayo.

Note that it may be healthier than mayonnaise, but it is by no means a truly healthy topping due to its still high-fat content.

How To Make Mayo

Making mayo at home is a fairly easy process. All you need is a hand beater and a blender, along with several ingredients that we’ll list in the recipe below.

You should also have an air-tight jarring system that lets you store your mayo in sealed jars that minimize the risk of spoilage. Follow these steps to produce high-quality mayo for your friends and family

  1. Crack three eggs in a food processor with one-quarter teaspoon lemon juice and one tablespoon whey
  2. Add one-quarter teaspoons of turmeric and dry mustard
  3. Blend these ingredients and add three-quarter cup of olive oil slowly to thicken the mayo
  4. Beat the mix after adding all the oil to create a consistent and creamy texture
  5. Store the finished mayo in a glass jar in your refrigerator

You can easily mix in other ingredients and spices if you want to change up your recipe. For example, you can mix in dill or even bits of pickle to make a more delicious recipe.

You can also add extra salt to boost its flavor or add peppers and other items to give your mayo a more diverse flavor. Store your extra air-tight jars in your cupboard or give away to friends as a gift.

Nutritional Value Table 

Mayo Nutritional Value of One Tablespoon

Total Fat4.91 grams
Carbohydrates3.51 grams
Cholesterol4 milligrams
Sodium105 milligrams
Protein0.13 grams

Mayo Recipes: Quick Table 

RecipesCaloriesPreparation Time
Chipotle Mayo4115 minutes
Sriracha Mayo855 minutes
Keto-Friendly Avocado Mayo9710 minutes

1. Chipotle Mayo

Chipotle has become a very popular ingredient in many different meals. This chipotle mayo recipe adds it to your mayo to give it a bit more of a kick.

You mix store-bought or homemade mayo with chipotle peppers, adobe sauce, cilantro, lime, salt and pepper, smoked paprika, and cumin.

You can then store this topping in a glass jar and use it on sandwiches, salads, and much more. Its nutritional value is about the same as mayo but has a much sharper taste.

We suggest this option for people who love spicy foods, such as those planning on making homemade tacos!

Calories: 411

Total Preparation Time: 5 minutes

2. Sriracha Mayo

Do you love sriracha and use it on just about anything? Make this five-minute mayo to add a little bit more to your life! It is perfect for burgers, salads, tacos, or even as a chip dip.

You can even layer it on top of chopped potatoes and bake it to make a delicious spicy potato meal.

Simply mix homemade or store-bought mayo with sriracha and chili powder to create a delicious taste. The proportions can vary based on your preferences.

We suggest this option for people who love sriracha but who also want a slightly lighter version of this topping.

Calories: 85

Total Preparation Time: 5 minutes

RELATED: 15 Delicious Chocolate Spice Cookie Recipes

3. Keto-Friendly Avocado Mayo

If you want a low-carb mayo recipe that is a lot healthier than store-bought varieties, try this recipe! You combine avocados, apple cider vinegar, mustard, garlic, and avocado oil.

Blend these ingredients together and pulse until smooth with a creamy texture.

This mayo has a rich avocado taste with and a higher fiber level that greatly reduces net carbs. It also has almost no fat and is useful in just about any sandwich, salad, or taco recipe.

Use it on your favorite Mexican dishes to bring out their flavor even more. It’s perfect for people trying to watch their weight!

Calories: 97

Total Preparation Time: 10 minutes

Frequently Asked Questions

What Kinds Of Carbohydrates Does Mayo Possess?

Mayo has only a few carbohydrates in the form of the eggs used in this meal. Even then, eggs don’t have many carbohydrates at all.

For example, 1-2 cups of mayo may only use one egg, which contains less than one-half gram of carbs. As eggs get diluted in the mayo, the carbs spread even further.

This means that mayo could work well on some low-carbohydrate diets. Note that mayo also has high fat and sodium levels, which may make it somewhat unhealthy.

This fact is important for people trying to lose weight. Other toppings, like mustard, may be more suitable.

Is Mayo Good For A Weight Loss Diet?

While mayo may fit in well with a keto or Atkins diet, it is usually not a good weight loss option. That’s because mayonnaise is very calorie dense, having between 57 to 100 calories per tablespoon.

Its high fat content can also be upsetting for some keto diets, even those with a high-fat content.

It is possible to lose weight while eating mayo, as long as you limit your intake. Top your sandwiches or salads with one or one-half tablespoons or less.

Doing so can help limit your fat and calories and may help you lose weight. That said, other toppings are usually a better option.

How Do Various Mayo Brands Differ?

Mayo brands differ mostly slightly by using different recipes and ingredients. For example, spicy mayo may use peppers and other items to make mayo hotter.

Other brands may use cheaper or non-organic ingredients, which lower the price but affect the mayo’s quality.

That said, the taste differences should be minor between these different recipes. Most mayo will taste pretty similar to other types, though some may last longer than others.

Experiment with a few different brands to identify an option that fits into your specific dietary needs.

Is Mayo Heart Healthy?

Mayo doesn’t have a lot of cholesterol, which may make it an okay option for people with heart issues.

However, it still has a high-fat concentration, which can be problematic for the heart. Most doctors state that mayo is not a suitable topping for a heart-healthy diet.

Talk to your doctor if you’re uncertain about whether you should eat mayo. They can test your heart health and gauge whether this topping is bad for you.

They can then help you find an alternative that you may enjoy, such as the healthier Miracle Whip.

Get Popular Variation Of Mayo Recipes Here

Mayo Taste Gives Aromatic Flavor To Enjoy As Your Favorite Recipe. An Ultimate Flavorful Treat!


  • Pick a recipe from the list above
  • Click the recipe name and visit the website
  • Collect the ingredients and cook the food
  • Enjoy – don’t forget to leave a review

Recipe Video

Jess Smith