Skip to Content

15 Deliciously Nutty Peanut Butter Whiskey Cocktails

Quick Answer: What Are The Best Peanut Butter Whiskey Cocktails?

The best peanut butter whiskey cocktail recipes that will have you ready for any occasion include the Screwball Peanut Butter Cup Whiskey Cocktail, Peanut Butter Whiskey Martini, PB & J Cocktail, Peanut Butter White Russian, Peanut Butter Cup Old Fashioned, Peanut Butter Grape Jelly Jell-O Shots, Peanut Butter Cookie Shots, Peanut Butter Root Beer, Peanut Butter Coffee Cocktail, Banana And Peanut Butter Cocktail, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Milkshake, Mint Chocolate Screw, The “King,” Peanut Butter Delight and the Skrewball Hot Chocolate.

While choosing a classic cocktail such as a Mimosa or Pina Colada is always a safe choice, sometimes it’s fun to try something new and exciting. 

We’re all familiar with the standard fruity cocktail, but when you’re in the mood for something a little more, shall we say, nutty, there’s nothing better than Peanut Butter Whisky. 

Yes, you heard us right. With this deliciously rich and smooth whiskey, all of your peanut butter dreams will come true (yes, we dream about peanut butter). 

If you’re as excited about this as we are, then be sure to check out these 15 super tasty Peanut Butter Whiskey cocktails, where you’ll find everything from PB cookie shots to steaming cups of Peanut Butter Whiskey hot chocolate. 

Deliciously Nutty Peanut Butter Whiskey Cocktails: Quick Table 

Recipe CaloriesPreparation Time 
Screwball Peanut Butter Cup Whiskey Cocktail390 (per serving)5 min 
Peanut Butter Whiskey Martinin/a8 min 
PB & J Cocktail201 (per serving)3 min 
Peanut Butter White Russian196 (per serving)5 min 
Peanut Butter Cup Old Fashionedn/a5 min
Peanut Butter Grape Jelly Jell-O Shotsn/a5 min
Peanut Butter Cookie Shotsn/a5 min
Peanut Butter Root Beern/a3 min
Peanut Butter Coffee Cocktail253 (per serving)10 min
Banana And Peanut Butter Cocktail n/a5 min
Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Milkshake1781 (per serving)5 min
Mint Chocolate Screwn/a5 min
The “King”n/a2 min
Peanut Butter Delightn/a5 min
Skrewball Hot Chocolaten/a5 min

1. Screwball Peanut Butter Cup Whiskey Cocktail 

It’s safe to say that when it comes to peanut butter and desserts, Peanut Butter Cups always come out on top. They were our go-to as kids and let’s be honest, still are as adults. 

Now, imagine that creamy, smooth chocolate and delicious nutty filling in the form of an alcoholic drink! That’s exactly what this cocktail offers. 

With hints of chocolate syrup, Peanut Butter Whiskey, chocolate liqueur, and milk, you’ll be transported to peanut butter cup heaven in no time. 

Calories Per Serving: 390

Total Preparation Time: 5 minutes 

2. Peanut Butter Whiskey Martini 

If you’re looking for a peanut butter-inspired drink that is quick and tasty, this martini variation is just what you need. 

This recipe uses the classic peanut butter and chocolate duo to make the perfect Peanut Butter Whisky dessert cocktail

With only two ingredients, Peanut Butter Whiskey and chocolate liqueur, this martini can be whipped up in just minutes. 

Don’t forget to add chocolate syrup and shavings to your glass to make this rich and lavish drink even more irresistible.

Total Preparation Time: 8 minutes  

3. PB & J Cocktail 

Is there anything more iconic in this world than the peanut butter and jelly combo in sandwiches? 

Whoever invented this duo is a true genius and whoever made it into a drink, is even smarter. 

With only three simple ingredients; Peanut Butter Whisky, fruit jelly and fruit bitters, this cocktail is full of nutty and sweet flavors and only takes 3 minutes to prepare. 

If you ask us, the PB & J blend would be perfect for those days when you’re feeling nostalgic and want a taste of your favorite childhood snack. 

Calories Per Serving: 201

Total Preparation Time: 3 minutes 

4. Peanut Butter White Russian

If you love the classic White Russian, then this peanut butter variation is a must. 

For anyone who isn’t familiar with this drink, a White Russian incorporates both vodka and Kahlua to make a deliciously creamy, coffee-flavored cocktail. 

This recipe puts a fun spin on the iconic duo by replacing the vodka with Peanut Butter Whiskey. 

We know, we know. How dare thee? But we promise you, if you give this one a chance, it will quickly become one of your favorites. 

Calories Per Serving: 196

Total Preparation Time: 5 minutes 

5. Peanut Butter Cup Old Fashioned 

For times when a smooth and strong drink is in order, you can never go wrong with a bourbon-based cocktail such as an Old Fashioned. 

And if that Old Fashioned incorporates delectable hints of peanut butter and chocolatey goodness? Well, then, we really can’t resist. 

With 3 different types of alcohol; Bourbon, Peanut Butter Whiskey and chocolate whiskey as well as aromatic hints of vanilla, this cocktail is extra boozy and extra sweet

Total Preparation Time: 5 minutes 

RELATED: 11 Holiday Cocktails: The Best For Celebrating

6. Peanut Butter Grape Jelly Jell-O Shots 

If you’re not feeling an entire PB & J cocktail, then perhaps this Jell-O shot variation is just what you’re looking for. 

These delicious cups of joy are full of nutty and fruity flavors, achieved by a variety of components, including grape soda, grape gelatin, PB whiskey and for the special ingredient: Peanut Butter and Jelly Moonshine. 

Serve these shots to your friends at your next get-together and you’ll be the hit of the party. 

Total Preparation Time: 5 minutes 

7. Peanut Butter Cookie Shots

If you’ve ever tried a peanut butter cookie, then you’ll know how delicious they are. 

If not, you’re seriously missing out. But don’t worry, with these shots, you’ll have your chance to get a taste of these scrumptious treats

Peanut Butter Cookie Shots taste just like the desert and feature PB Whiskey, Vanilla Vodka, sea salt as well as actual peanut butter and brown sugar for the rim. 

They’re easy to make, sweet, delicious and the perfect addition to your next party. 

Total Preparation Time: 5 minutes 

8. Peanut Butter Root Beer 

Peanut butter is delicious on its own, and Root Beer is delicious on its own, but who knew the two could pair so nicely together? 

For a creamy and luscious soda-inspired drink, mix together Peanut Butter Whiskey, Bailey’s Irish Cream and Root Beer

This easy, 3-ingredient recipe is truly divine and will quickly become one of your go-to cocktails. 

Total Preparation Time: 3 minutes 

9. Peanut Butter Coffee Cocktail

https://www.pinterest.pt/pin/914862416799328/

Satisfy both your peanut butter and coffee cravings with this Peanut Butter Coffee Cocktail. 

Simply mix together PB Whiskey, coffee liqueur as well as regular coffee (for an extra strong caffeinated flavor) with a bit of cream or milk (this is optional) and you’ve got the perfect pick-me-up complimentary drink for your afternoon snack! 

Bonus: this recipe can be served hot or cold and only takes 10 minutes to prepare. 

Calories Per Serving: 253

Total Preparation Time: 10 minutes

10. Banana And Peanut Butter Cocktail 

This recipe takes a little more time and patience but we assure you, it’s worth the wait. 

The Banana And Peanut Butter Cocktail uses a super interesting infusion technique where slices of bananas are placed in a jar, topped with sherry and then sit for 72 hours. 

Once this is done you’ve got yourself delicious banana-infused sherry, perfect for mixing with your favorite peanut butter and scotch whiskeys! 

Oh and don’t forget a few chocolate coffee bitters to enhance the flavors even more! 

Total Preparation Time: 5 minutes

RELATED: 17 Easy Crown Royal Cocktails

11. Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Milkshake

Cocktails in the form of boozy milkshakes are literally what dreams are made of and this whiskey Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup drink is giving just that. 

For a premium dessert cocktail that will be sure to wow your guests all you have to do is mix together vanilla ice cream, chocolate liqueur, PB Whiskey and all the Reese’s inspired treats you can get. 

Add on whipped cream and mini Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups as garnish and you’ve got the ultimate PB extravaganza. 

Calories Per Serving: 1781

Total Preparation Time: 5 minutes

12. Mint Chocolate Screw 

One often doesn’t think of mixing peanut butter and mint but this cocktail proves that the two can actually make a delicious duo. 

With really opposing ingredients like this, it’s important to get the perfect balance of flavors. 

For that, this recipe compliments the PB Whiskey and Creme de Menthe (mint-flavored alcohol) with a hint of cream as well as Creme de Cacao (chocolate liqueur). 

Mint chocolate screws are nutty, sweet and refreshing. What’s not to like? 

Serve these up next St. Patty’s Day to really get the party going. 

Total Preparation Time: 5 minutes

13. The “King” 

For another PB and banana-inspired drink, this cocktail is a delicious mix of Peanut Butter Whiskey, banana liqueur and Irish Cream. 

It’s full of rich, nutty and fruity flavor that will be sure to burst into your mouth with every sip (it’s not called “The King” for any reason). 

The best part: it only requires a couple of minutes of your time. 

Total Preparation Time: 2 minutes

14. Peanut Butter Delight 

Holiday enthusiasts, get ready because this one is dedicated to you! 

There are so many wonderful things about the festive season, one of which, I think we can all agree on, is the treats. 

Christmas cookies just wouldn’t be the same without a delicious cup of eggnog and although traditionally eggnog is paired with rum, this recipe uses Peanut Butter Whiskey for a nutty twist

Don’t forget to add the chocolate sprinkles for some decorative fun! 

Total Preparation Time: 5 minutes

RELATED: 31 Tequilla Cocktails are trending| what are you craving

15. Skrewball Hot Chocolate 

There’s nothing like a steaming hot cup of hot cocoa on a cold winter’s day- or so we thought. 

This recipe takes the regular, old hot chocolate to a whole new level with its deliciously smooth and chocolatey PB Whiskey and hot cocoa mix. 

For an even richer experience, make sure to add a generous serving of whipped cream on top! 

Total Preparation Time: 5 minutes

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is Peanut Butter Whiskey? 

Peanut Butter Whiskey is a flavored whiskey that was first released on the market in 2018. 

The most popular kind of peanut butter whiskey is Skrewball. Skrewball’s deliciously smooth and peanutty blend was invented by a young, Cambodian male immigrant and his wife in San Diego. 

What Does Peanut Butter Whiskey Taste Like? 

Peanut Butter Whiskey is a smooth alcoholic beverage that contains a strong burst of peanut butter flavor as well as hints of caramel, coffee and vanilla.

When you first take a sip of this whiskey, you’re initially hit with both sweet and savory flavors. 

In fact, it’s so full of rich and diverse ingredients, it’s actually often described as more similar to Baileys than it is to bourbon. 

Take one sip of this PB Whiskey and you’ll hardly think you’re drinking whiskey at all, but rather a peanut butter dessert- with a kick! 

Can You Drink Peanut Butter Whiskey On Its Own? 

Yes! As we just described, PB whiskey is more of a dessert than anything and can definitely be consumed (and enjoyed!) on its own.

However, if you still find it a little too potent by itself, any of the mixers provided in the above recipes are also a great option.

15 Deliciously Nutty Peanut Butter Whiskey Cocktails

0 from 0 votes

Be sure to check out these 15 super tasty Peanut Butter Whiskey cocktails and have fun.

Directions

  • Pick a recipe from the list above
  • Click the recipe name and visit the website
  • Collect the ingredients and cook the food
  • Enjoy – don’t forget to leave a review

Recipe Video

Jess Smith