Skip to Content

15 Awesome Paleo Sweet Potato Pie Recipes

Quick Answer

Don’t have enough time to read through all of this guide? Not a problem. Here’s a quick summary of the 15 most awesome paleo sweet potato pie recipes that you can add to your “to bake” list:

  1. Paleo Sweet Potato Pie with Almond Flour Crust (by Paleo Grubs)
  2. Gluten Free Paleo Sweet Potato Pie (by The Roasted Root)
  3. Paleo Sweet Potato Pie (by The Roasted Root)
  4. Simple Paleo Sweet Potato Pie (by Natural Family)
  5. Paleo Easy and Simple Crustless Sweet Potato Pie (by Cotter Crunch)
  6. Quick Paleo Sweet Potato Pie (by Thriving Paleo)
  7. Paleo Sweet Potato Pie (by Dan Churchill)
  8. Paleo Sweet Potato Pie with Maple Syrup (by Hollywood Homestead)
  9. Healthy Paleo Sweet Potato Pie (by Veggie Converter)
  10. Sweet Potato Shepherd’s Pie Paleo (by The Frayed Apron)
  11. Mini Paleo Sweet Potato Pies (by Empowered Sustenance)
  12. Mini Sweet Potato Pie with 5 Simple Ingredients (by Secretly Healthy Home))
  13. Paleo Sweet Potato Pie Tarts (by What Great Grandma Ate)
  14. Paleo Chocolate Sweet Potato Pie (by Paleo Hacks)
  15. Sweet Potato Pie with Marshmallows Paleo (by Unbound Wellness)

Sure, even though Thanksgiving favorites like pumpkin pie and apple pie are totally delicious, nothing quite compares to the creamy and sweet flavor of the classic sweet potato pie.

The only question is, which paleo sweet potato pie recipes are the best?

If you are currently in need of some assistance, then rest assured that you have come to the right place.

In this guide, we are going to be talking you through our hand selected list of the top 15 paleo sweet potato pie recipes out there right now.

Aprons at the ready? Just keep on reading!

All of these awesome recipes are totally paleo-friendly! Plus, as we’re sure that you will have been able to see from the list, there are plenty of different options for you to choose from, too.

Whether you’re in the mood for a chocolate treat or a classic sweet potato pie – this paleo-friendly list is the perfect place to gain some baking inspiration!

Paleo Sweet Potato Pie Recipes: Quick Table

Before we jump any further into this guide, we first want to provide you with a table to summarize all of the recipes that we have selected for you.

This will help you to compare each one to decide which recipe is going to be the best fit for you.

Let’s take a look:

NameCaloriesPreparation Time

Paleo Sweet Potato Pie with Almond Flour Crust (by Paleo Grubs)
1981-2 hours
Gluten Free Paleo Sweet Potato Pie (by The Roasted Root)20590 minutes
Paleo Sweet Potato Pie (by The Roasted Root)326120 minutes
Simple Paleo Sweet Potato Pie (by Natural Family)315120 minutes
Paleo Easy and Simple Crustless Sweet Potato Pie (by Cotter Crunch)17590 minutes
Quick Paleo Sweet Potato Pie (by Thriving Paleo)315135 minutes
Paleo Sweet Potato Pie (by Dan Churchill)27060 minutes
Healthy Paleo Sweet Potato Pie (by Veggie Converter)185210 minutes
Sweet Potato Shepherd’s Pie Paleo (by The Frayed Apron)41035 minutes
Mini Paleo Sweet Potato Pies (by Empowered Sustenance)80 (per mini pie)120 minutes
Mini Sweet Potato Pie with 5 Simple Ingredients (by Secretly Healthy Home)18860 minutes
Paleo Sweet Potato Pie Tarts (by What Great Grandma Ate)21460 minutes
Paleo Chocolate Sweet Potato Pie (by Paleo Hacks)201105 minutes
Sweet Potato Pie with Marshmallows Paleo (by Unbound Wellness)18860-90 minutes

15 Awesome Paleo Sweet Potato Pie Recipes

1. Paleo Sweet Potato Pie With Almond Flour Crust (By Paleo Grubs)

https://www.pinterest.co.uk/pin/292452569563079152/

Kicking this list off, we have selected this sweet potato pie with almond flour crust made by Paleo Grubs!

This tasty recipe will allow you to make a paleo sweet potato pie with the sweetly nutty addition of almond flour crust. You’ll love it!

2. Gluten Free Paleo Sweet Potato Pie (By The Roasted Root)

If you want to prepare some sweet potato pie that is going to be both gluten free and paleo-friendly – look no further than this recipe created by The Roasted Root.

This recipe is both paleo and gluten free, so it’s perfect for any dietary requirements you might need to cater to.

3. Paleo Sweet Potato Pie (By The Roasted Root)

On the search for a classic sweet potato pie recipe that also just so happens to be paleo friendly? You’re in luck with this recipe by The Roasted Root!

This recipe is perfect for preparing a hearty and sweet sweet potato pie that also just so happens to be paleo friendly, too.

4. Simple Paleo Sweet Potato Pie (By Natural Family)

If you’re not a natural cook (but still want to make a delicious pie to share) this is the recipe for you! Ideal for beginners, this simple recipe follows an easy to follow method that requires very little know-how.

5. Paleo Easy And Simple Crustless Sweet Potato Pie (by Cotter Crunch)

If you’re not a huge fan of crusts, then you’ll absolutely love this recipe!

By Cotter Crunch, this recipe will allow you to whip up a sweet potato pie that doesn’t feature any crusts. It’s a great healthy alternative to enjoy when you’re in the mood for something light!

6. Quick Paleo Sweet Potato Pie (By Thriving Paleo)

If you don’t have much time to spare in the kitchen but still want to prepare a delicious sweet potato pie – you’ll be making a good choice to prepare this recipe by Thriving Paleo.

Created specifically for those who don’t have a lot of time to dedicate to baking, this recipe follows a simplified cooking method and fewer ingredients, too.

7. Paleo Sweet Potato Pie (By Dan Churchill)

If you’re already big in the cooking world, then we’re sure that you might have already heard of Dan Churchill!

An extremely popular cooking blogger, Dan is known for preparing a variety of recipes (including paleo-friendly recipes) and this Sweet Potato Pie is an example of his talent for baking!

Next time you’re in the kitchen, consider following his recipe for a paleo sweet potato pie eating experience like no other.

8. Paleo Sweet Potato Pie With Maple Syrup (By Hollywood Homestead)

Got a sweet tooth?

This sweet potato pie recipe by Hollywood Homestead is totally paleo-friendly and incorporates some delicious maple syrup to satisfy any sweet tooth cravings that you might currently be having.

It can even double up as a heart dessert!

9. Healthy Paleo Sweet Potato Pie (By Veggie Converter)

If you’re in the mood for sweet potato pie but want to make sure that it’s still healthy – you might want to add this recipe to your collection!

This tasty (and easy) recipe will allow you to whip up a healthy paleo sweet potato pie in no time at all.

10. Sweet Potato Shepherd’s Pie Paleo (By The Frayed Apron)

Offering a slight alternative to the classic sweet potato pie, this recipe is paleo-friendly and incorporates popular Shepherd’s pie ingredients including mushrooms and peas!

Simply perfect for a cold night.

11. Mini Paleo Sweet Potato Pies (By Empowered Sustenance)

If you’d like to prepare something smaller than a classic-sized pie – this recipe by Empowered Sustenance will allow you to prepare a batch of mini paleo sweet potato pies ideal for snacking on.

12. Mini Sweet Potato Pie With 5 Simple Ingredients (By Secretly Healthy Home)

https://www.pinterest.co.uk/pin/1004654629351551278/

Keeping with the theme of mini pies – this next recipe is perfect for those who want to enjoy a paleo sweet potato pie but perhaps don’t want the meal to be too heavy.

Perfect as a lighter snack, this simple to follow recipe uses just 5 ingredients and will allow you to make mini sweet potato pie in just a few moments.

13. Paleo Sweet Potato Pie Tarts (By What Great Grandma Ate)

Are you planning to prepare sweet potato pie for more than one guest that follows a paleo lifestyle?

If you are, then you might be interested in trying out this recipe, as it will allow you to prepare mini sweet potato pie tarts that are completely paleo.

Besides being ideal for more than one guest who follows a paleo lifestyle, these are also great to make if you want to be able to serve canapes.

14. Paleo Chocolate Sweet Potato Pie (by Paleo Hacks)

Are you a fan of chocolate or want to prepare a sweet potato pie for some who are? If you answered yes, then look no further than the paleo chocolate sweet potato pie recipe by PaleoHacks!

This simple and quick sweet potato pie recipe incorporates a little bit of chocolate to satisfy those cravings, and is totally paleo friendly.

It also utilizes simple ingredients, so you’ve probably already got everything you need in your kitchen already.

15. Sweet Potato Pie With Marshmallows Paleo (By Unbound Wellness)

Last but certainly not least, the final recipe that we have selected is this delicious one from the Unbound Wellness.

It’s absolutely perfect for those who are in need of a sweet tooth craving fix!

Unlike the other paleo sweet potato pie recipes that we have shared in this list, this particular paleo-friendly sweet potato pie recipe is suitable for those on a paleo diet and includes a topping of fluffy marshmallows for a touch of sweetness.

What’s not to love? This is the perfect paleo option for anyone that is in the mood for something sweet.

Final Thoughts

All in all? Just because you might be on a paleo diet doesn’t mean that you need to miss out on holiday favorites such as the sweet potato pie – and we hope that our recipe list has given you a dose of baking inspiration.

The only question left to ask is, which paleo sweet potato pie recipe are you going to try first? Thank you for taking the time to read this guide, and goodbye for now.

15 Awesome Paleo Sweet Potato Pie Recipes

5 from 1 vote

In the mood for some sweet potato pie paleo style? We’ve got you covered. Click through to discover 15 delicious recipes here!

Directions

  • Pick a recipe from the list above
  • Click the recipe name and visit the website
  • Collect the ingredients and cook the food
  • Enjoy – don’t forget to leave a review

Recipe Video

Jess Smith