Skip to Content

8 Amazing Goldschlager Substitutes For The Taste Of Your Drinks & Food

If you like your drinks with a bit of spiciness and kick to them, along with a lovely warm feeling underneath it all, then you will probably have come across Goldschlager.

Goldschlager Substitutes For Drinks & Food

Goldschlager is a type of cinnamon schnapps originally from Switzerland, which largely tastes sweet, but has a spicy and warm undertone to it all.

Besides its unique flavor, it also has a very unique appearance, because it has lots of golden flakes floating in it.

As you can guess, it’s the perfect drink for the winter months, because it looks so refined and keeps you nice and warm. However, it can sometimes be difficult to get hold of, and not to mention reasonably expensive.

So what do you do?

Well, there are a handful of great Goldschlager substitutes out there for you to drink or use when cooking food. We’ve got 8 of the best substitutes described in our handy article below.

Read on to learn about each of these 8 Goldschlager substitutes for drinks & food, with information on how each of them captures the Goldschlager taste and spirit.

Nutritional Value Table

Goldschlager SubstitutesAlcohol Content
 Cinnamon Cocktail Flavoring33%
Cannella Cinnamon Cordial20%
Peligroso Cinnamon Tequila42%
Cinnamon Whiskey33%
Cinnamon Schnapps50%
Liquor Quik20-30%
Cinnamon Liqueur From deZir20%
Spiced Rum35%

Goldschlager Substitutes For Drinks & Food

1. Cinnamon Cocktail Flavoring

One of the best things about Goldschlager is its warm undertone, which makes it a very welcoming drink and one that you can enjoy in winter.

This warmth is mainly created by the use of cinnamon in the drink, which gives it a spicy and hot edge.

As a result, if you’ve got a cocktail that you want to make taste like Goldschlager, then you can add some cinnamon cocktail flavoring to it.

This is an easy and affordable way to give your drink that warm, spicy edge that Goldschlager is famous for.

Make sure to use the cocktail flavoring responsibly, because it actually has small levels of alcohol in it.

This is because the cinnamon cocktail flavoring is a form of bitters, which are herbal alcoholic preparations.

Of course, you don’t have to have alcohol to enjoy the warm cinnamon edge that you get with the alcoholic Goldschlager.

There are non-alcoholic cinnamon schnapps drinks out there, just be sure to read the label to confirm that it is indeed alcohol free.

For example, Still Spirits’ “Hot Cinnamon Schnapps” drinks is a great non-alcoholic choice to add to your non-alcoholic drinks.

How To Substitute

Cinnamon Cocktail Flavoring is a delicious and convenient alternative to Goldschlager, a popular cinnamon-flavored liquor. It is perfect for various occasions, including dinner parties, holiday parties, or even breakfast.

2. Cannella Cinnamon Cordial

The drinks company Canella makes a Cinnamon Cordial that is great for taking small, spare sips of or mixing with a cocktail.

It’s a great substitute for Goldschlager. The drink is Cannella’s flagship drink, so you know it’s good!

Cannella Cinnamon Cordial is a delicious and slightly dry liqueur that is cinnamon-forward, getting its unique flavor from a blend of four different varieties of cinnamon, giving you a whole range of subtle tastes.

On top of that, some other spices are thrown into the mix, in order to give it an even more complex mixture of warmth and edge. As a result, it’s a perfect drink for cold nights, just like Goldschlager.

Unfortunately, it’s not much cheaper than Goldschlager. With that being said, it’s still well worth trying.

How To Substitute

It is a little tricky but worth trying. The taste of the two products is different enough that it would be tough to replace one with the other, but the ingredients are similar

3. Peligroso Cinnamon Tequila

This is a cinnamon flavor tequila liquor from Peligroso, which means that it’s going to offer you a slightly different taste to the traditional Goldschlager liquor.

However, if you’re a fan of tequila or tequila liqueur already, then this is going to be an essential flavored variety to try.

This drink gives you a completely warm, welcoming feeling, leaving just a hint of heat on your tongue with each sip.

As a result, it’s perfect for winter evenings like Goldschlager is, but it’s also the ideal shot for a typical night out with your friends.

It uses cinnamon and other ingredients to get a spicy aroma that is sure to make your taste buds tingle, making it a great substitute for Goldschlager for drinks and food.

How To Substitute

Peligroso Cinnamon Tequila is a cinnamon-flavored tequila made from agave, sugar, and various spices. The substitution for Goldschlager is made by substituting Peligroso Cinnamon Tequila for Goldschlager. The substitution of Goldschlager is worth trying for those who don’t like the flavor of Goldschlager.

4. Cinnamon Whiskey

This is one of the best substitutes for Goldschlager, because there are so many different varieties of cinnamon whiskey that you can choose from.

Though they all have that classic warm and spicy taste that Goldschlager does, you’ll be able to find your very favorite blend thanks to the sheer amount of choice.

Plus, on top of that, you’ll get the famously smoky flavor of whiskey. If you’re a whiskey fan already, then getting a cinnamon flavored whiskey is going to be a great pick.

As for which cinnamon whiskey to get, we recommend a few.

The “Fireball” is probably the most well known variety, and is sure to give you a very warm and spicy taste, while also being smooth. Better yet, it’s cheaper than Goldschlager!

Aside from that, we’d also suggest Jack Daniel’s warm and spicy Tennessee Fire or the thick and sweet Red Stag Spiced from Jim Beam.

Jack Daniel’s and Jim Beam are both major names in the whiskey business, so you can guarantee there is quality there.

How To Substitute

Goldschlager is a cinnamon-flavored hard liquor. To substitute it with a similar flavor, use cinnamon whiskey. In addition to its taste, Goldschlager is also known for its whipped cream topping. To replace, make whipped cream from heavy cream and top with a cinnamon stick or sprinkle with cinnamon sugar.

5. Cinnamon Schnapps

Since Goldschlager is a cinnamon schnapps itself, why not look to other brands of cinnamon schnapps?

You’re sure to find plenty of great Goldschlager substitutes for drink and food, each bringing their own warm and spicy twist to the schnapps classic.

Better yet, many of them will be cheaper than Goldschlager!

If you want a straightforward substitute to Goldschlager that is very crisp and warm, then Arrow Cinnamon Super Schnapps is a good choice. It recaptures the same warm and spicy edge.

Alternatively, you could go for cinnamon schnapps brands that have gold flakes in them, just like Goldschlager!

For example, Bols Gold Strike and Danziger Goldwasser both have the same refined appearance, as well as the classic cinnamon taste.

For something a little different to Goldschlager, you can get the “Original Cinn” from Hiram Walker.

This cinnamon schnapps gives you the usual warm and (softly) fiery taste that you expect from Goldschlager, but adds hints of vanilla and orange to the mix.

These really make the flavor more complex, the wildly different tastes all coming together surprisingly well.

How To Substitute

To substitute Goldschlager, you may try some other brand with cinnamon schnapps, such as “Original Cinn.” You may get a similar fiery taste out of it. However, be ready to taste other flavors, but it is worth trying once in a while.

6. Liquor Quik

Liquor Quik is a popular brand that makes loads of different liqueur flavorings, allowing you to make your drink taste exactly how you want it.

Naturally, they make a cinnamon schnapps flavor too, which is a great substitute for Goldschlager for drinks and even food.

The version from Liquor Quik is named “Goldrush Cinnamon Schnapps”, and it has flakes of real gold floating inside it just like Goldschlager does.

On top of that, it has a great taste. Goldrush Cinnamon Schnapps will give you a perfect mix of sweetness and warmth, the kind that only cinnamon could bring to a drink.

Better yet, it’s a very cheap and affordable flavoring, making it an even better substitute for Goldschlager.

How To Substitute

Goldschlager is a tasty, orange-flavored liqueur that is made with a variety of ingredients, including cinnamon, honey, orange peel, and citrus. You may substitute Goldschlager with Liquor Quik, made with various ingredients, including vanilla, rum, cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove, and you will love the delicious taste you will get.

7. Cinnamon Liqueur From DeZir

If you want a substitute for Goldschlager that is a bit less spicy and full-on, then the cinnamon liqueur that deZir sell is a great choice to consider.

This cinnamon liqueur still gives you the great cinnamon flavor that will transform the drinks you add it to, but it’s a more mellow one.

The spice is still there, just in lesser amounts. Instead, it gives you a thoroughly sweet and smooth taste on top of it.

How To Substitute

Goldschlager is a tasty, orange-flavored liqueur that is made with a variety of ingredients, including cinnamon, honey, orange peel, and citrus. You may substitute Goldschlager with Liquor Quik, made with various ingredients, including vanilla, rum, cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove, and you will love the delicious taste you will get.

8. Spiced Rum

The final Goldschlager substitute for drinks and food on our list is spiced rum.

This isn’t always going to be the best or most accurate substitute, since it isn’t specifically cinnamon flavored, but it does give you a hint of what you can get from Goldschlager.

More specifically, you’re getting the spicy aspect, which warms you up as you drink it.

There are loads of varieties of quality spiced rum out there, you just have to pick the one closest to what flavor you want.

Captain Morgan Spiced Rum is a classic, though it has hints of caramel and vanilla alongside the spice. Sailor Jerry Spiced Rum also offers the same.

The “Botanical Rhum” from Boukman is also a great pick, which gives you the usual spiciness as well as a hint of bitter orange.

Orange complements spice well, we find, and almost comes close to capturing that cinnamon flavor.

How To Substitute

Spiced Rum is used as the substitute for Goldschlager, adding sugar syrup. The sugar syrup provides the sweetness and depth of flavor that the liqueur would otherwise have. However, choose your spiced rum wisely that is close to the taste of Goldschlager.

What Is Goldschlager?

Now that we’ve looked at the substitutes, it’s worth looking at what makes Goldschlager such a special taste to try and replicate in the first place.

Goldschlager is a cinnamon schnapps that was originally made in Switzerland, but it’s now made in Italy. Its name hints at the flakes of real gold that float in the liquid, giving it a refined appearance.

In terms of alcohol content, Goldschlager has a 43.5% ABV. It has a flavorful blend of syrupy cinnamon mixed with hotter touches of spice, which makes it the perfect drink for warming yourself on a winter evening.

Final Thoughts

Goldschlager is a cinnamon schnapps, but if you can’t get some then our list of 8 substitutes will help!

Frequently Asked Questions

What Kind Of Liquor Is Goldschlager?

Goldschlager is a German schnapps with a light, honeyed taste. It is a clear liquor with a unique, distinctive flavor that is mildly sweet and hints of honey. It is made with pure malt and alcohol, water, and other flavorings like lemon and orange.

Is Goldschläger Similar To Fireball?

Goldschläger is a liqueur that is a bit sweeter and lighter than Fireball. It is made of brandy, caramel, and spices. Goldschläger is a sweet and smooth liqueur with a distinct cinnamon flavor. It is not as fiery as Fireball, which has a higher alcohol content and a fruity flavor.

Is Goldschlager Cinnamon Or Peppermint?

Goldschlager is a unique, hard cinnamon-flavored schnapps made with the finest ingredients and then aged for one year in the finest oak casks. Goldschlager is perfect for mixing with hot or cold coffee or iced tea.

8 Goldschlager Substitutes For Drinks & Food

5 from 5 votes
Prep time

5

minutes
Cooking time

0

minutes
Total time

5

minutes

Goldschlager is a famous cinnamon schnapps drink that’s warm and spicy, but expensive. Read our guide to 8 Goldschlager substitutes for food & drink.

Ingredients

  • Cinnamon Cocktail Flavoring

  • Cannella Cinnamon Cordial

  • Peligroso Cinnamon Tequila

  • Cinnamon Whiskey

  • Cinnamon Schnapps

  • Liquor Quik

  • Cinnamon Liqueur From DeZir

  • Spiced Rum

Directions

  • Choose your favorite substitute from the list given above
  • Follow the directions given in the recipe after having substituted the ingredient in the correct ratio

Recipe Video

Jess Smith