Skip to Content

12 Best Sweet Relish Substitutes You Should Try Once

Take your daily sweet relish, and you’ll get tons of vitamin A and vitamin K but do you know that it has high sodium content? Or something you must already know–many of them taste like sour candy and have tons of calories because of the sugar.

Sweet relishes are a part of many people’s regular meals, and it’s because they add flavor to the meal and make it more delicious. 

You can experiment with your dishes, and the next thing you know is that you have made something different–something tastier.

As for the concern, many look for the best sweet relish substitute. What can we do to replace sweet relish with something less problematic that won’t bring down your holistic approach to having a complete meal? Best Sweet Relish Substitute

Stick to this blog to find out.

Substitutes For Sweet Relish

Here are some cherry-picked substitutes for sweet relish to try out today.

SubstitutesCalories Per Serving
Chopped Dill Pickles12
Green Bell Peppers20
Green Olives145
Freeze Dried Dill0
Apple Butter173
Piccalilli Relish33.3
Crushed Pineapples57
Bread And Butter Pickles83.3

1. Chopped Dill Pickels

Chopped Dill Pickels

Your probiotics and your sweet taste–dill pickle are known for both. Serving as the best substitute for sweet relish, this is a fermented, tasty, and perfect option.

Cucumbers are preserved in dill pickles. It’s the dill that distinguishes them. The flavor of dill pickles would still be similar to a sweet pickle relish because dill & dill seeds are common elements used during sweet pickle relish recipes.

How To Substitute

You can simply replace them with your sweet relish and give yourself something new–hamburgers, sausages, pizzas, etc. Make sure to use every ingredient fresh and pay attention to the fermentation process according to the taste.

2. Capers

Capers Best Sweet Relish Substitute

They were developed in the regions of Spain, Morocco, and Italy. Capers are lemony in taste along with spicy and salty sensations as you taste them.

They have a strong flavor that is somewhat similar to olives. They work wonders in marinades as well as salad dressings.

You can, without a doubt, replace the sweet relish using capers if indeed the dish’s purpose of the sweet relish is really to add sharpness and bring it to a balance.

Without providing much substance, capers can enhance the vinegar flavor that sweet relish provides. You can have them in greens or pasta dishes frequently topped with sweet relish.

How To Substitute

Capers are used in Mediterranean cooking techniques and serve as an excellent alternative for sweet relish. As for taste, it brings an olive-like and tangy flavor to the dish. So, try using it in the right proportion suited to your demands.

3. Celery

Celery Best Sweet Relish Substitute

Grown as a vegetable ever since the discovery of the artifact, celery is a wetland plant with in Apiaceae family.

If you enjoy green smoothies, you undoubtedly have a few celery stalks at home. You may still use celery stems to make your favorite quick sweet pickle relish.

It would be great to combine sliced garlic and onion with wine vinegar and olive oil to marinade the diced or cut celery stalks. Next, add the spices and capers, then salt and pepper to taste.

Additionally, you now have a tasty alternative to sweet pickle relish for sandwiches, sausages, and hamburgers!

How To Substitute

You can consume celery as a substitute for sweet relish or simply raw. Since the Apiaceae family, this has been developed as a vegetable since vestige.

4. Green Bell Peppers

Green Bell Peppers

The Green Bell Pepper comes from a plant belonging to the Solanaceae family and is sweetly harvested before maturing.

They are used with less pungent pepper varieties as “sweet peppers.” Unfortunately, green bell peppers have a little disagreeable flavor with green undertones.

Sweet relish is frequently added in recipes to give them more texture. Green peppers that have been diced are an excellent substitute for Sweet Relish if you want to add some color to your sandwiches, soups, or dips but don’t have any on hand.

The best ones are also crisp and juicy. Green bell peppers might assist you in achieving balance in your recipes because of their low acidity and robust flavors.

How To Substitute

Green bell peppers are a sweet variety of bell-shaped pepper that appear in meals that have been thoroughly cooked. They are used as a substitute for a healthy life in vegan recipes since they are crispy.

5. Cucumbers

Best Sweet Relish Substitute Cucumbers

A revitalizing, nourishing, and remarkably adaptable addition to any diet.

Cucumbers can be used in specific recipes that require sweet relish, even if you don’t have the perfect time to prepare sweet relish.

Cucumbers are fruit, even though many people mistake them for vegetables. We understand that cucumbers don’t have a robust flavor.

Nevertheless, they excel in providing surface and texture. As a result, cucumbers go well in hamburgers, sandwiches, soups, sauces, and dips.

They will add a top fair note with a hint of that fantastic, crisp flavor.

How To Substitute

Cucumber is an excellent replacement for Sweet Relish if you’re looking for something with a distinctive appearance and flavor. In addition, it might very quickly be included in salads and other dishes.

RELATED: Is A Pickle A Fruit Or A Vegetable?

6. Chutney

Best Sweet Relish Substitute Chutney

Because Sweet Relish is related to East Indian Chutney, it is an excellent replacement. The word for mending, chatni or catni, is an Indian word.

Chutney comes in various forms with various flavors, such as spicy, sour, and sweet.

Many of the same ingredients used in Sweet Relish may be found in actual Indian chutney variations.

Sweet Relish is a Westernized version of getting to know Europeans via English. It traveled from the UK to the Age Of exploration after they returned home with it.

How To Substitute

Choose a chutney with a flavor profile similar to Sweet Relish since there are several to choose from. The closest taste matches include British chutney or green mango chutney.

7. Green Olives

Best Sweet Relish Substitute Green Olives

Green olives are olives that have not yet been entirely torn. However, they have an identifiable flavor because of the manner in which they collected lye before even being tenderized in oil.

Their flavor profile is unique. Compared to regular black olives, they have a more vibrant flavor.

Green olives have a subtle nutty flAs a result, and they have a green and a sharp, acidic finish. Green olives won’t appear pleasant to many. However, if you aren’t one of them, you can chop a few and use them in place of sweet relish.

They are a fantastic addition to salads and sauces. To give your sandwiches more variety and a different taste.

How To Substitute

Usually, green olives are thought of as a simple garnish that can be added to a drink or pizza. However, olives are wholesome food on their own. They contain lots of solid fat.

8. Freeze Dried Dill

Freeze Dried Dill

Dill gives food a freshness that is unmatched by any other flavor. It is a seasoning that is commonly used in Eurasia and is used to enhance the flavor of meals.

Its zesty flavors lift the dish’s other ingredients, and the green undertones add great depth. Dill that has been iced lasts very long.

A spoonful of chopped fresh dill equals one tablespoon of freeze-dried dill.

Use freeze-dried dill in place of sweet relish in dips, soups, dressings, and other foods that call for a burst of flavor and freshness.

How To Substitute

It has a delicious flavor. It’s the perfect swap for sweet relish. Salmon, chicken, veggies like potatoes, zucchini, carrots, and eggs go nicely with dried dill.

9. Apple Butter

Apple Butter

Apples fall into the delicious category of fruits that are full-flavored, naturally sweet, generally juicy, and fresh. Apple butter is made using the correct ingredients and a mixture of these delightful qualities.

Apple butter transforms your dinner into a natural treat by mixing the sweet flavor of pickles with its charm. Rich and full, apple butter adds a powerful flavor to your food even when used as a substitute.

Apple butter is an excellent spread for pastries, bagels, and cupcakes. Alternately, use it as a condiment for your hamburgers and hot dogs. Apple butter is a fantastic addition to salads if you want to give them a little sharpness.

How To Substitute

Apple butter is a viable option for being a substitute. However, you have to make sure that the apples are fresh and juicy. This will ensure the apple butter tastes delicious and is a perfect fit in your dish.

10. Piccalilli Relish

Piccalilli Relish is a sweet, hot, and sour relish. It’s traditionally made with chopped red bell peppers, celery, onions, raisins, and sugar.

Piccalilli Relish is a great way to add a touch of sweetness to a dish without adding sugar or other sweeteners. You can also use leftover vegetables in it.

When making a dish such as turkey sandwiches, it is easy to substitute the sweet relish with piccalilli relish.

How To Substitute

Condensed milk is a substitute for eggs as it gives you a sweet and milky flavor with reduced water content. The syrup texture is perfect to add in desserts or drinks.

11. Crushed Pineapples

Crushed pineapple is a perfect substitution for sweet relish. Sweet relish is a common ingredient in many recipes, and the easiest way to make a substitution would be to swap it for crushed pineapple.

You can use crushed pineapple in place of sweet relish in most recipes. It is a healthy alternative to sugar-laden toppings and a good vitamin C source.

How To Substitute

You can substitute sweet relish with crushed pineapples equally

12. Bread And Butter Pickles

Try bread and butter pickles if you don’t have the sweet relish and need a substitute. However, it would taste too much like a sweet relish, which you would need to put into a sandwich. However, the texture would be perfect for a burger.

Bread and Butter Pickles are a sweet relish with a sweeter taste than dill pickles. Burgers and sandwiches often contain them. If you would like to substitute Bread and Butter Pickles for sweet relish, you may use it the same way your recipe calls for sweet relish.

How To Substitute

Replace sweet relish with bread and butter pickles equally.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Relish As Same As A Pickle?

Fruits and vegetables kept with vinegar, sugar, or a mixture of the two are known as relish. You would be preparing a relish rather than a pickle because, despite their importance for preservation, sugar and vinegar are not the main ingredients by weight.

What Does Relish Taste Like?

The ideal pickle relish must be sweet but not overly so. We discovered this after tasting a wide variety of relishes since some are so sweet they almost have a sour candy flavor.

What Relish Is Used On Hotdogs?

Pickle relish is widely popular for adding a variety of flavors to the hotdog. It enhances the taste and gives the experience of trying something different rather than a traditional hotdog.

Are Indian Relish And Dili Relish Identical?

The Indian relish features a unique ingredient called cabbage and tastes like dill relish with a dash of sweetness. Green tomatoes are allegedly the secret element in Indian relish recipes.

What Can I Use In Place Of Burger Sauce’s Sweet Pickle Relish?

The typical side item is chopped sweet pickles. They provide a crunchy and tart texture that contrasts with the soft nature of sour cream and dressing, which are sometimes substituted for sweet pickle relish when it is unavailable.

The 12 Best Substitutes For Sweet Relish

Prep time


Cooking time


Total time



Some of the best cherry-picked substitutes for sweet relish to try out today.


  • Chopped Dill Pickles

  • Capers

  • Celery

  • Green Bell Pepper

  • Cucumber

  • Chutney

  • Green Olives

  • Freeze Dried Dill

  • Apple Butter

  • Piccalilli Relish

  • Crushed Pineapples

  • Bread And Butter Pickles


  • Choose your favorite substitute from the list given above
  • Follow the directions given in the recipe after having substituted the ingredient in the correct ratio.

Recipe Video

Jess Smith

Hello World!

Tuesday 20th of September 2022