10 Stunning Peanut Butter Pie Recipes

Whether you prefer smooth or crunchy peanut butter, it can be a delicious treat. It manages to be both sweet and savory, having a tasty nut flavor. It is also a relatively healthy treat since it is high in nutrients such as magnesium and protein.

Because of its popularity, peanut butter has been used in lots of different desserts. One of our favorite peanut butter desserts is the peanut butter pie.

If you are planning an event or dinner party, you may want to try making a peanut butter pie. This humble classic will likely be loved by all of your guests.

If you are interested in this pudding, here is a list of our favorite peanut butter pie recipes out there.

1. Reese’s Peanut Butter Pie From Pillsbury

If you are a lover of Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups, this may be the ideal recipe for you. These delicious candies have been spread throughout the smooth peanut butter filling. This filling rests on top of a layer of fudge, which will be beloved by people who have a sweet tooth. In turn, the fudge layer is atop a pastry layer. For your convenience, use ready-made pie crusts. This will save you time, money, and energy.

Even if you are a novice baker, you may have heard of Pilsbury. This baking company has garnered a positive reputation due to its high-quality products. As a result, you can trust this company to provide an amazing recipe.

2. Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie From The Food Network

Secondly, if you love the flavor combination of peanut butter and chocolate, you cannot go far wrong with this incredible recipe. It is constructed of three layers. The first layer is made from a nutty pie crust. The second is a creamy and peanut butter filling. Meanwhile, the final layer is a chocolate topping.

If this sounds mouth-watering to you, you may want to give this recipe a try. It comes from the Food Network, a reputable baking channel that is renowned for its stunning recipes. It will serve 8 people, meaning that it is ideal for a party or family to consume.

3. No-Bake Peanut Butter Pie from All Things Mamma

Up next, this peanut butter pie recipe is recommended for people who do not have a lot of time. The recipe is super straightforward and, because it is non-bake, will not take very long to make. Another pro of this recipe is that it requires very few ingredients, resulting in it being incredible for people who are baking on a budget.

If you make the recipe, you will get an airy and creamy texture that is perfect for desserts. It has a rich and deep flavor that will be adored by anyone who gives it a try. This pie is constructed from a layer of graham crackers which is topped with a filling made from peanut butter, cream cheese, and confectioner’s sugar.

4. 5 Ingredients Peanut Butter Pie from Cooking Classy

This elegant recipe will create a pie that looks really sophisticated. All of your friends or family members will be delighted when they see this beautiful dessert. Despite its sophistication, the peanut butter pie is also very simple to make. It requires only 5 ingredients, making it an optimal choice for people with busy schedules.

In addition, if you adore Oreos, you may want to consider this recipe. Its base has been made from a pre-made Oreo pie crust that tastes astonishing and saves you time. The recipe also provides a host of tips to make your baking experience more seamless.

5. Peanut Butter Pie from BBC Good Food

Like the previous recipe, this one from BBC Good Food is built on a base made from Oreos. If you love a sugary taste to your desserts, this peanut butter pie may be right up your alley.

If you are searching for a straightforward recipe, we suggest this one. All of the ingredients can be easily acquired from your supermarket. The ingredients include cream cheese, icing sugar, and peanut butter (obviously!) It will not take long to follow this recipe. Nor is it a very complicated method of making peanut butter pie.

6. Peanut Butter Pie from All Recipes

As you can see from the photos, this peanut butter pie looks phenomenal. Because of this, it will be the centerpiece of any gathering or social event. To decorate, this recipe advises using chocolate peanut butter cups. These decorations result in the dessert looking ridiculously tempting.

For convenience, this peanut butter pie recipe has been provided in two forms, namely through written instructions and an informational video. Thus, you can use whichever form of media most appeals to you. Consequently, this versatile recipe not only looks amazing and tastes delicious, but is also extremely convenient.

7. Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie from Kevin & Amanda

Next, this pie has been coated in chocolate. As a consequence, it will be the perfect treat for chocolate lovers. This pie is comprised of an Oreo base, a creamy peanut butter filling, with a chocolate and peanut butter topping. If you love your desserts to be sweet and high in sugar, look no further.

In fact, this dessert is comparable to a giant chocolate and peanut butter cup. You may want to eat them if you are a fan of these candies. It is trouble-free to bake yet appears incredibly impressive.

8. Healthier Peanut Butter Pie from Casa & Crews

If you want to achieve the delicious taste and texture of a peanut butter pie without all of the sugar and fat, you may want to try this healthier version of the popular dessert. To get rid of refined sugar, this recipe replaces it with honey. This means that you do not have to sacrifice the sweetness of the pie when making a more nutritional version.

Aside from being healthier than other pies, this version is also simple to make. You will need only a handful of simple-to-acquire ingredients in order to complete this method. If you have a birthday party coming up, this recipe will be ideal for it.

9. Vegan Peanut Butter Pie from Loving it Vegan

Maintaining a vegan diet can be very rewarding. Not only can you feel the moral benefits from not consuming products made or derived from animals, but there are also plenty of health advantages. However, you can sometimes miss out on delicious foods because they have not been tailored to your diet.

Luckily, there are vegan recipes available for fans of peanut butter pie. This is a brilliant example of a vegan dessert. This means that you do not need to sacrifice your ideals in order to taste a mouth-watering peanut butter pie. The recipe uses vegan ingredients such as vegan butter, whipped coconut cream, and vegan chocolate. The result is an enticing pie that is perfectly suitable for vegans and non-vegans alike.

10. White Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie from Inside BruCrew Life

The final recipes in this list utilize white chocolate instead of milk or dark chocolate. This gives the recipe a unique taste that may be sweeter than some of the other pies. If you cherish white chocolate or love sweet desserts, you may want to give this a taste.

The pie has three layers, all of which are succulent. The crust is made from Nutter Butter biscuits. The middle layer is constructed from gooey peanut butter. Last but not least, the top layer is a creamy white chocolate creation. These layers harmonize to create an alluring pudding. This pie will be ideal for holidays, such as Easter, Thanksgiving, or Christmas.

Final Thoughts

If you are considering making a peanut butter pie, we heartily recommend giving it a go! This dessert is a fan-favorite in most households for a reason. That reason is that it is extremely tasty and has a pleasant texture.

The recipe is also quite customizable. As evidenced by this list, there are a variety of crusts and toppings for you to choose from. For instance, you can try crusts made from crackers, Oreos, or traditional pie crust. To help you make a decision, we have included a range of stunning peanut butter pie recipes.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where do peanuts come from?

The peanut is believed to originally be native to South America. Nowadays, it is grown in places across the world that have hot climates, including Africa, Australia, and Asia. The reason for this is that peanuts will thrive best in warm climates.

Are peanut butter pies healthy?

No, peanut butter pies are not very healthy. Though there are nutritional benefits to peanut butter, it is not the healthiest of desserts. They tend to be very high in calories, fat, and sugar. Sugar can be bad for the body because it can result in several health problems, including tooth decay and obesity. Meanwhile, fats will raise your cholesterol, thus heightening your chances of suffering a heart attack.

As a consequence, peanut butter pies should only be consumed occasionally. Portions should be small in order to maintain a balanced and nutritional diet. Fortunately, there are alternative peanut butter pie recipes that are healthier than others. For instance, the recipe from Casa & Crews has made alterations so that the desert is healthier.

Is peanut butter gluten-free?

Yes, a lot of peanut butter brands are gluten-free. As a result, you can still eat them even if you suffer from coeliac disease. Of course, it is always a good idea to check the label of a peanut butter jar before consuming it.

Sadly, not all peanut butter pie recipes are gluten-free. If you are having trouble locating one that is, we suggest this luscious recipe from Flippin’ Delicious. Its crust is made of crushed gluten-free chocolate cookies.

Jess Smith
Latest posts by Jess Smith (see all)

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *